No such thing as 'fair tax' when it comes to schools
March 28, 2010 01:00 AM | 682 views | 8 8 comments | 11 11 recommendations | email to a friend | print
DEAR EDITOR:

Allen Hirons lamented in a recent letter to the editor that exempting seniors from paying the education portion of the property taxes did not seem fair to him even if these seniors paid for education for 30 to 40 years before being exempted. Let me ask you: have you ever met a "fair tax"? These two words when used together are a perfect example of an oxymoron.

In considering the writer's comments about the exemption for seniors, I had to ask myself: Is there unfairness in any of the following as it relates to my understanding of who pays or does not pay an education tax?

* Homeowners without children pay for public education.

* Non-homeowners with children in public school do not pay for public education.

* Homeowners with several children in public school pay no higher a tax rate for education than homeowners with only one child in public school.

* Homeowners who home school or who pay tuition for private education pay for public schools even though they are reducing the education cost for the county.

* Non-homeowners who are foreign nationals illegally in the U.S., have children in public school and are paid under the table in cash (does the MDJ reporting about the pay of certain construction workers at the new courthouse ring a bell?) pay no federal, state or local taxes of any kind except for sales tax.

Yeah, taxes stink and no tax is "fair" to everyone. As for me, when my work brought me to Georgia my two children had only a combined eight years remaining before both graduated from Lassiter High School but I paid education taxes for more than 20 years before being exempted. So be it; they received a fine education.

Heck, I would be happy if we just had a Board of Education that had a little more appreciation as to where all those tax dollars are coming from to finance their seemingly unending string of embarrassments.

Roger Chagnon
East Cobb
Comments
(8)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Response to Indi Joe
|
April 10, 2010
Apparently you should do your research before making incorrect comments Inidan Joe. It is the parents that pay for sports. The county does not fund sports. The parents pay a $250-$300 dollar fee plus fundraising activities. This pays for uniforms, home and visitor stands, consession stands, and field houses. We even pay for the track and all upkeep on the field. Next time. ask before writing so you know what you are talking about. In addition, the reason people want to live in Cobb County is because it is a great school district. Now we have no money. That equates to schools going down hill, YOUR house value going down hill, and trash moving in...all because you don't want to contribute. Please don't complain when all the hispanics take over your neighborhood because you were part of the problem and not part of the solution! Greed Inidan Joe! You are the type of person that has created the horrible situation America is in right now!
A Senior
|
April 01, 2010
Trust me, you don't want to see a fight like

you 'will get if you dare touch this exemption. It

will be ugly because as Seniors we know how to

fight and really stick it where the sun don't

shine. We have had lots of practice and this is

one fight that you WILL NOT WIN!!!!!!!!!
anonymous
|
March 31, 2010
Once again Indian Joe - you don't know what you are talking about. - Parents are asked to pay all kinds of money - for everything

field trips, plays, sports, art, uniforms - band and concert, instruments, fund raising, school supplies, extra projects the teacher wants to do, you name it we pay. It is $10 here $100 there every month.

NCHS parent
|
March 30, 2010
Indian Joe, Parents DO PAY for sports activities, that's why we have Booster Clubs and fundraisers. Girls Basketball was $250, Lacrosse another $250, and other sports also have fees in that range. The schools will have gyms and fields, but the sports teams are parent money.
Indian Joe
|
March 29, 2010
Why can't we just get back to schools being for education purposes. If you child wants to play sports, parents should be required to ante up the cost of uniforms, coaches, etc. Be in the band - same sceniro - drama - that too - choir - that should also be included - cheerleading, same. I realize some will say this makes for a well rounded child - but back in the day, when they cut art classes at my son's school, the parents stepped in and volunteered, even to going to printing companies and getting scrap paper. Why should school taxes go to fund anything other than education? So a football, basketball, etc player can get a big scholarship and maybe earn megabucks, or worse yet, so they can go to college and never graduate (look at the graduation stats on atheletes at many major schools). With all of this "fair" business, what is fair when taxes go to funds programs only a minority of students take part in? Oh, I can hear the outrage now even as I finish doing this comment. Guess it is only "fair" if your home or your student benefits - as long as everyone - including seniors have to foot the bill for a select group.
misterbill
|
March 29, 2010
Alan Faircloth--

I agree, but i was told my reactions were "kneejerk" and I was picking on the poor and the illegals who are easy targets.

Fighting Ready-- I agree with you also. It is sad that when things get financially tough, those who want to keep the status quo for issues such as school funding, reach out to get money any way they can and yet criticize our lawmakers when they do the same.
Fighting Ready
|
March 28, 2010
I could not have said it better Mr. Chagnon. When I become eligible, I hope that the benefit is still there for seniors. My income will definitely be less, but my medical costs will be higher, especially when you take into consideration what just happened in D.C. recently. What about the inefficiency of the CCSD, run by an inept board & dictator superintendent? What about legislation that addresses the groups that do not pay into the school fund or the inequalities of those groups that do? When there are so many other groups of people who do not pay any OR as much property taxes as a Cobb County property owner, why is the focus for more funds ONLY on the seniors? They are evidently an easy target, because it requires less thinking & effort by the politicians. I am already geared up to fight all the ridiculous garbage that is being passed nationally and I am ready for the local garbage that is being readied, even though I am not yet 62. Bring it on!
Alan Faircloth
|
March 28, 2010
Not to sound too much like D.A. King, but I cannot help but wonder about the true impact of illegal immigration on our schools. I lived next door to a house where several families lived together in one house. It was way too many people for a small 3 Bedroom house. How many kids of illegal immigrants are being educated without corresponding payment of taxes supporting the schools. Seems unfair to accuse those 62 and older of not paying their fair share, when people who have and are breaking the law aren't paying their fair share and actually have kids being educated.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides