The bigger the government, the harder to manage
by Melvyn L Fein
May 26, 2014 12:00 AM | 1592 views | 3 3 comments | 39 39 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Melvyn Fein
Melvyn Fein
Years ago, Ronald Reagan warned us that over-sized government was a serious problem. The evidence he was correct keeps pouring in. The VA scandal is just the latest example of how organizational gigantism can injure people.

Liberal Democrats, with Barack Obama in the lead, keep telling us they must protect us from ourselves. They assure us their programs are intended to promote social justice and rational planning. Be this in energy or health, they argue that they know best.

Then something like the Veteran’s Administration cover-up of incompetent scheduling comes to light and we learn — as we should have known all along — bloated bureaucracies have a way of getting things wrong. Especially when part of the government, and therefore not subject to marketplace discipline, they often go rogue.

At moments such as this, the president’s apologists explain the executive structure is simply too large for anyone to administer effectively. The president is, after all, just one man, and he can’t be everywhere. Nor can he know everything; hence, he must depend upon his subordinates.

But who are his subordinates? Jack Kennedy depended upon advisors regarded as “the best and the brightest.” FDR, of course, had his “brain trust.” And what does Obama have? A kiddy corps! And a crony corps!

Let us start with Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi. They are not part of his administration, but they have been delegated essential tasks, such as writing the stimulus legislation and designing ObamaCare. Thus, in many ways, they are as responsible as anyone for the recent additions to the Washington mess.

Question: Does anyone trust Harry or Nancy? Does anyone regard them as mental giants? Who believes they are incorruptible public servants who deserve to be in charge of setting our communal agenda?

Remember, Nancy told us that we had to pass the ObamaCare legislation in order to find out what was in it. This was not only an example of abdicating legislative responsibility, but of engaging in a crapshoot with the health of the nation. Some leadership here!

As for Harry, when he is not accusing the Koch brothers of global warming or asserting Mitt Romney did not pay his taxes, he is seeking a constitutional amendment to overturn the Bill of Rights or staging an attack on senate procedure via the nuclear option. More brilliant leadership!

What about the executive branch itself? Does anyone believe Jay Carney is an honest and penetrating analyst of administrative policy? Or is he more like Art Carney; that is, a sideman in a comedy routine? Reporters are tolerant of his badinage, but does he really deserve to be the voice of the United States?

And what about those other voices, such as the spokespersons for the State Department? Jen Psaki obviously has the experience and gravitas to represent our country to the rest of the world. And how about Obama’s advisors? Tommy Veitor was a wonderful example of their maturity with his, “Dude, that was two years ago,” explanation of the Benghazi cover-up. He gave us confidence the nation is in good hands.

As for the political advice Obama gets, which frequently seems decisive, David Plouffe and Daniel Pieffer constantly impress with their deep thinking. They may have the president’s interests at heart, but do they have the nation’s?

This list could be extended indefinitely, but it gives an idea of what can happen when the management of an already bloated government is delegated to a band of incompetents. When a gang of venal ideologues, supplemented by juvenile ciphers, takes charge, we get the mess we are currently enduring.

This puts the lie to the entire Liberal agenda, which asserts centralizing decisions in Washington promotes rationality. The truth is the opposite. The larger the government gets, the more unmanageable it becomes — a problem exacerbated when those who naively think they know best take the helm.

Melvyn L. Fein Ph.D. is professor of sociology at Kennesaw State University.
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Walt Clausmann
May 27, 2014
The management that is in place are primarily supporters and donors for the democrats aren't they? Do they really have any true management experience in the departments they are appointed to oversee? Any real management experience at all? Usually not, they are just there to get a government pension and add to a resume for private industry. Unfortunately, both sides play the game so no one will bring this fact up at appointment hearings. In the past six years we have seen money thrown at "stimulus" programs that never had a chance to succeed, but they rewarded Obama's and other politicians backers and some voted for it based on promises to fund wasteful projects. As long as these games continue in politics, it will never get better. This is where the apathy in the voters come from. Where is the real "change" that we all need? Right now, it is just a waste of time to even vote for these egocentric idiots
May 28, 2014
Four Star General Eric Shinseki, decorated Vietnam vet with 38 years experience, leads the VA.

Yeah, I'd say he's got "true management experience."
May 29, 2014
@anon- A lifetime military person may not have what it takes to run a big business. In the military you give direct orders and people have to follow or they can get court martialed. In government, the unions tell you what to do. Besides the military he was a director for companies and organizations- not in a daily leadership/decsion making role. If he is such a great leader and manager, why is it such a mess?
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides