Marx, liberals and today’s identity politics
by Melvyn L Fein
April 14, 2014 12:00 AM | 1847 views | 10 10 comments | 39 39 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Karl Marx wanted workers to identify as workers. He believed only when they began looking after their own interests would they be able to throw off the yoke of capitalist oppression.

Today, liberals purvey a similar attitude with respect to women and minorities. Women are thus told they must identify themselves, first and foremost, as women, while African-Americans are asked to consider themselves primarily as African-American. Being American — or human — comes in a distant second.

Marx advocated this tactic because he didn’t want workers to side with their bosses. Liberals likewise do not want women or blacks to support their reputed oppressors. In the case of women, these are men; whereas for blacks, it is whites in general.

In both instances, the goal is to prepare the way for a rebellion. For Marxists, this was intended to destroy capitalism; for liberals, it is to totally remake America along neo-socialist lines.

And so women and African-Americans are encouraged to think of themselves as oppressed workers. If they do, they will surely align with the proletarian cause and help defeat their common tormentors.

This makes false consciousness, that is, identifying with men or whites, a serious transgression. Men, particularly Republican men, they are repeatedly told, are waging a war on women, while whites, particularly conservative whites, are obviously trying to reinstate slavery.

These arguments would be risible — except that many young women and most blacks seem to buy them. They do not appear to understand that identifying with liberal causes today constitutes the true false consciousness.

Consider the situation of women. If men are the enemy, does marriage make sense? And if marriage does not make sense, does having children make sense? “Sleeping with the Enemy” made a wonderful movie title, but it is a terrible way to create a family.

Married women know this. They are therefore more likely to vote conservative. A majority of single women do not. They fail to realize that they are being encouraged to become old maids and/or unwed mothers. As a result, they are prepared to sell out their own interests for the sake of free birth control.

No! Women and men are not enemies! To the contrary, they ought to be allies. Yes, some men are abusive, but this is not the norm. If it were, we would all be doomed.

Consequently, young women must learn that this business of men earning more for the same work is a liberal canard. They instead need to discover that success and intimacy are not necessarily inconsistent. They must likewise realize that when men win, they also win. This is not false consciousness, but reality.

With respect to African-Americans, don’t they remember that Abraham Lincoln freed the slaves, that Republican votes helped pass the civil rights laws and that Richard Nixon started affirmative action? Since when have conservatives been pro-slavery — except in liberal propaganda?

Conservatives insist that blacks learn to help themselves, but how is this anti-black? Has helpless dependency somehow morphed into the contemporary version of freedom? Successful parents demand that their children perform so that they too can be successful. Shouldn’t we, as a society, make similar demands of blacks so that they can be successful?

So what has the liberal parody of false consciousness delivered in the way of benefits? Not much! The sad fact is that women are discovering a bad economy is bad for everyone — not just men. After all, women too are losing jobs, and women too are suffering under Obamacare.

As for African-Americans, they may cheer at rhetoric that castigates conservatives as their nemesis, but they are doing even less well on the job market. A black president is a wonderful symbol, yet symbolism alone does not put food on the table.

No, women and blacks are Americans and should be proud of it. They must also realize that because we are all in the same boat, hurting the whole hurts them too.

Melvyn L. Fein Ph.D. is professor of sociology at Kennesaw State University.
Comments
(10)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Kevin Foley
|
April 17, 2014
@ Double Wide - Y'mean careful like you as in not identifying myself? At least I man up here and take responsibility for what I write. Twomey does too, even though he has no clue. Liberals made an issue of Romney's religion. Really? It wasn't your team demanding government sanctioned transvaginal probes? Give me a break.

As for sledgehammers, buddy, I get a lot of abuse around here in case you haven't noticed. So I happily swing back. As I told Pete Borden, I'm not a paid MDJ piñata.
CobbCoGuy
|
April 18, 2014
Y'mean careful like you as in not identifying myself?

Kinda like you never call out one of your main supporters on here about his/her anonymity?
why not
|
April 15, 2014
Who could be a better spokesman for women and African-Americans than an old, conservative white man!
Kevin Foley
|
April 14, 2014
Mel - "Married women know this. They are therefore more likely to vote conservative."

Reality! - President Barack Obama won the two-party vote among female voters in the 2012 election by 12 points, 56% to 44%, over Republican challenger Mitt Romney.
BenTwomey
|
April 14, 2014
After liberals poisoned the waterhole by making an issue of Romney's religious beliefs, aoready lies about the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Days Saints and preying on people's natural fear of th unknown. "Fearmongering", I think, is the proper terminology.
Kevin Foley
|
April 14, 2014
Yeah, that's right Ben, women weren't at all concerned about "legitimate rape," rape as "God's will," or "binders of women." And they aren't worried middle aged white right wing males want to take away their reproductive rights and they certainly don't care if their access to contraceptives is cut off.

CobbCoGuy
|
April 14, 2014
KF,

What are the stats among MARRIED women?
Kevin Foley
|
April 15, 2014
@Cheet-oh boy - Why don't you do some of your own research and stop relying on me to educate you?
Ben Twomey
|
April 16, 2014
Foley, you and I both knwo tnat none of that had anything to do with Romney's defeat. Stop trying to confuse the issue.
CobbCoGuy
|
April 16, 2014
KF,

I was trying to be subtle, and civil, and save you the embarrassment, although I don't know why I should.

Your stats pertain to ALL women. Dr. Fein's comment pertains to MARRIED women.

Perhaps you should read a little more carefully before you wade into an adult discussion swinging a sledgehammer.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides