Land of the weak; home of the losers
by Melvyn L Fein
September 01, 2013 10:15 PM | 1479 views | 4 4 comments | 36 36 recommendations | email to a friend | print
You’ve probably heard the news. The Cato Institute found that, in many states, people can earn more money from government welfare programs than they can if they take a paying job. Evidently in Hawaii a family of four can make the equivalent of $60,000 per annum on the dole.

What you may not be aware of is that this underestimates the amount of money the poor have available. When, several decades ago, the sociologist Christopher Jencks decided to study the “out-go,” as opposed to income, of the underprivileged, he found that they spent almost twice as much as they theoretically earned.

How, you may ask, is this possible? The answer is that not every dollar received came in over the table. Nor were all of them legal. Many even came from friends and relatives. This then explained all that “bling” and those large-screen TVs.

Once upon a time, Americans took pride in their “can-do” abilities. Prepared to meet virtually any challenge, they assumed they could do whatever needed doing. Was there a continent to be tamed? They were ready to take it on. Could they construct a rocket to the moon? No sweat!

But now we seem to regard ourselves as a nation of weaklings. We require someone else — preferably Uncle Sam — to take care of us. The question is not what we are going to build — our president has already assured us that we do not personally build anything — but how we are going to divvy up the spoils.

Ours, we have heard over and over again, has become a dependency, or some say, an entitlement culture. The issue is what will we be given, not what will we achieve. He or she who can persuade the federal government to cough up the most loot is the winner in this race to the bottom.

In fact, winners must win. They must take on difficult tasks and succeed in accomplishing them. Only then do they deserve the respect that has traditionally been accorded victors. Otherwise they are losers — no matter how loudly they crow about deserving the best.

Despite this, millions of Americans apparently feel too weak to succeed on their own. They whine and wail and gnash their teeth about how unfair life is and demand that the winners be taken down a peg or two.

Not long ago our national motto was “the land of the free and the home of the brave,” whereas today it is more accurately “the land of the weak and the home of the losers.” It isn’t that we do not boast millions of young people prepared to defend our freedoms; rather it is that the protesters and lay-abouts are currently setting the national agenda.

Still, when I ask my students at Kennesaw State University how many of them aspire to be losers, not a single arm goes up. On the other hand, when there is reading to be done or papers to be written, a large proportion look for the easy way out. As long as they can pass a course, they do not worry about passing with flying colors.

Plainly, hard work is for chumps. Nevertheless, as Malcolm Gladwell observed in his book “Outliers,” truly successful people dedicate years of concerted effort to becoming good at what they do. Because they want to win, they devote themselves to becoming strong enough to prevail.

We must never forget that if our objective is for everyone to do equally well, we must set standards everyone can meet. That means we must become a nation of less than mediocrities. Because half of us are always below average, this half can only be accommodated by very low benchmarks.

The truth is that not everyone can win; yet if we are to be a nation of winners, we must both work at it and acknowledge those who come out on top. The false God of victory for all merely ensures defeat for all.

Melvyn L. Fein, Ph.D., is a professor of sociology at Kennesaw State University.

Comments-icon Post a Comment
Ivana Biggen
September 03, 2013
You are asking the wrong question of your students. None will admit to be an aspiring loser, they just want things given to them and to not work. So next time ask who wants to be paid a fair wage for doing as little as possible or nothing at all. if you get hands up, those are your losers
East Cobb Senior
September 02, 2013
It is both interesting and somewhat depressing to observe how we have gone from a nation on the rise to a nation in demise; from a people of high expectation to a people of great trepidation; from a culture in sync with morality to a culture being sunk by immorality and from a nation founded on principles of hard work, freedom, personal responsibility and individual liberty to one of cradle to grave servitude to government dependence.

The political class, whose only interest is power, has mastered the art of obfuscation in their indoctrination and subjugation of the masses. The U.S. Treasury has become the vehicle by which they have successfully herded nearly half the country’s population into the vicious downward spiral of dependency.

Our founding fathers recognized the sparks that would ignite the flames leading to our greatness as nation. The recipe or formula to create those sparks was transcribed into our founding documents, The Declaration of Independence and our Constitution, with its Bill of Rights.

Great leaders not only lead but provide inspiration and hope with a vision for a better tomorrow. They adhere to those masterful documents and do not succumb to the temporary and often detrimental trends of pop culture. They recognize that in order to maintain reasonable stability and not “tilting” the ship of state too far left or right, while moving forward, they rely on the foundational principles upon which this nation was created.

Sadly, the 20th century produced few great leaders in the tradition of President Ronald Reagan with his leadership and inspirational vision of “A shining city on a hill”. Much to our chagrin, so far none have yet appeared in the 21st. Our nation has not totally slipped into the abyss of 3rd world status, but we are at the precipice nearing a point of no return. Let’s hope that that Great Leader will immerge in either 2014 or 2016 to lead us back to the “Promised Land” that we know as “America, One Nation Under God”.

bill millette
September 06, 2013
east cobb senior

Excellent message. Thank you!!
September 02, 2013
Excellent column!

Yes, we've become the Land of the weak; home of the losers. I would add to this that the U.S. has become the sanctuary of the Fraidy Cat. In America there is an unrelenting message that we should be afraid of everything and that not being afraid is suspicious, contemptuous and unacceptable behavior.

Our Man In Powder Springs
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides