Judge strikes down NYC sugary-drinks size rule
by Jennifer Peltz, Associated Press
March 11, 2013 04:22 PM | 980 views | 4 4 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
This May 31, 2012 file photo shows a display of various size cups and sugar cubes at a news conference at New York's City Hall. A judge struck down New York City's groundbreaking limit on the size of sugar-laden drinks Monday, March 11, 2013 shortly before it was set to take effect, agreeing with the beverage industry and other opponents that the rule is arbitrary in applying to only some sweet beverages and some places that sell them. (AP Photo/Richard Drew, File)
This May 31, 2012 file photo shows a display of various size cups and sugar cubes at a news conference at New York's City Hall. A judge struck down New York City's groundbreaking limit on the size of sugar-laden drinks Monday, March 11, 2013 shortly before it was set to take effect, agreeing with the beverage industry and other opponents that the rule is arbitrary in applying to only some sweet beverages and some places that sell them. (AP Photo/Richard Drew, File)
slideshow

NEW YORK (AP) — A judge struck down New York City's groundbreaking limit on the size of sugar-laden drinks Monday shortly before it was set to take effect, agreeing with the beverage industry and other opponents that the rule is arbitrary in applying to only some sweet beverages and some places that sell them. .

"The loopholes in this rule effectively defeat the stated purpose of this rule," Manhattan state Supreme Court Justice Milton Tingling wrote.

Further, the Board of Health went beyond its authority in approving the size limit, he said. The restriction was supposed to start Tuesday.

The size-limit rule strayed into territory that should belong to the elected City Council, not the board appointed by Mayor Michael Bloomberg, Tingling wrote.

The city Board of Health approved the measure in September. Championed by Bloomberg, it follows on other efforts his administration has made to improve New Yorkers' eating habits, from compelling chain restaurants to post calorie counts on their menus to barring artificial trans fats in restaurant food to prodding food manufacturers to use less salt.

The city has said that while restaurant inspectors would start enforcing the soda size rule in March, they wouldn't seek fines — $200 for a violation — until June.

Soda makers, restaurateurs, movie theater owners and other business groups sued, asking a judge to declare the measure invalid. In February, they asked Tingling to bar the city from enforcing the regulation while the suit played out.

City officials have called the size limit a pioneering move for public health. They point to the city's rising obesity rate — about 24 percent of adults, up from 18 percent in 2002 — and to studies tying sugary drinks to weight gain. Care for obesity-related illnesses costs government health programs about $2.8 billion a year in New York City alone, according to city Health Commissioner Dr. Thomas Farley.

The supersize-drink crackdown will "have significant public health effects, and the sooner that happens, the better," city lawyer Mark W. Muschenheim said in court in February.

Critics said the measure is too limited to make a meaningful impact on New Yorkers' waistlines. But they said it would take a bite out of business for the eateries that have to comply, while other establishments still will get sell sugary drinks in 2-liter bottles and supersize cups.

Beverage makers had expected to spend about $600,000 changing bottles and labels, movie theater owners feared losing soda sales that account for 20 percent of their profits, and delis and restaurants would have had to change inventory, reprint menus and make other adjustments, according to court papers.

"These are costs which these businesses are not going to be compensated for," and the money will be wasted if the court ultimately nixes the law, James E. Brandt, a lawyer for the American Beverage Association and other opponents, told the judge in February.

Critics also said the restriction should have gone before the elected City Council instead of the Bloomberg-appointed health board. The city says the panel of doctors and other health professionals had both the authority and expertise to make the decision.

___

Follow Jennifer Peltz at http://twitter.com/jennpeltz



Copyright 2013 The Associated Press.

Comments
(4)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Think again
|
March 11, 2013
While it's very kind of Mayor Bloomberg to want the best for its citizens....and I do agree that many of us need to limit the amount of sugar that we ingest... HOWEVER - by doing what he is doing is taking away a FREEDOM. Small as it may seem - choosing how much soda you want to drink is a FREEDOM. Do you really want the government telling you how much soda you can drink? Come on, American. Wake up. We cannot allow government to regulate how much of a LEGAL soft drink we can consume. This is just ridiculous.
stayoutofmylife
|
March 12, 2013
Good points, 'Think again.' If someone is obese and obsessed with drinking soda and other sugary drinks, this micromanaging isn't going to stop them. It has to be a personal choice. Can't believe any normal minded person would want someone else dictating to them what they're allowed to purchase and consume.

It was also drastically affecting countless businesses and their practices. And I sure don't need to hear Moo-chelle tell me or others what we need to be doing for our kids. Have no interest listening to her opinion or 'expertise.' Maybe if she dropped 30 pounds, then she'd be more believable. Until then, no thank you to the control freaks.
Vorant
|
March 11, 2013
Bloomberg needs to be committed to a mental health facility for observation, he's obviously not in touch with reality.
Gringo Bandito
|
March 11, 2013
Bloomberg just wants to ban high capacity assault beverages.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides