Hinojosa still recommends denying school
by Lindsay Field
lfield@mdjonline.com
Jun 27, 2012 | 4382 views | 21 21 comments | 7 7 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA — Even though Smyrna Academy of Excellence leaders gave the Cobb school district more information, including revealing where the school will be located, Cobb Superintendent Dr. Michael Hinojosa is still recommending denying their start-up charter petition at the school board’s Thursday night meeting.

“Their effort was good, but the results were not good enough to make a recommendation for approval,” Hinojosa said Tuesday. “We still have concerns about facilities, finances and academic programs. We appreciate working with them, but it just wasn’t enough in any of those areas to change our recommendations.”

In other business, the board will also

consider renewing Walton High School’s petition, awarding a contract to renovate Campbell Middle School and approving Hinojosa’s recommendation for a new chief financial officer.

Smyrna Academy of Excellence supporters began working to open the school about 15 months ago with the help of Jimmy Arispe, a former Cobb Schools teacher and administrator.

“(We) are disappointed in the district’s recommendation to not approve such an exceptional school and much-needed educational option for the children and families of our area,” Arispe said.

The school has received more than 1,900 letters of support from residents, area colleges and businesses and has pre-registered 1,300 students. Supporters have pledged $583,000, and school leaders were awarded two Race to the Top grants and have been invited to apply for a third valued at $12.9 million, $10 million of which could go toward a facility.

At the June 13 work session, the school board talked for more than an hour about the proposed school, eventually approving a motion from board member Tim Stultz, who represents southeast Cobb, to give school leaders more time to beef up their petition.

They had until 5 p.m. on June 18 to work with their developer, McCay-Kinchin and Associates in Marietta, to give the district details about where they will be located.

Arispe said the data was turned in on time and the school’s location has been narrowed down, but they are still not saying where it would be.

“The property is for sale and has been vacant for at least three years,” he said. “However, there is an active but expiring lease on the property. Due to these circumstances, the exact location of the property is not being disclosed.”

Arispe said the facility will include more than 115,000 square feet of academic space and a 20,000-square-foot gymnasium on 15 acres along the East-West Connector in Austell.

David Banks, who represents northeast Cobb, said Monday that he’s never been for or against charter schools and hasn’t decided whether to go along with the superintendent’s recommendation.

“If these parents feel like this is what is best for these students, I will not put myself in a position to say that the state has authority over what is best for your child,” he said. “Even though I may think it’s a mistake on their part, they have the right to do that.”

Walton High School’s petition for a five-year renewal has earned Hinojosa’s recommendation. The east Cobb school, which has been open since 1998, is seeking its third renewal.

“They just have a great legacy of success,” Hinojosa said.

In other business, the board will consider awarding a $4.3 million contract with Classic Plains Construction of Marietta to renovate Campbell Middle School in Smyrna.

The project includes adding band, choral and orchestra classrooms; modifying student restrooms; painting the interior and exterior of the building; adding PE lockers; replacing the HVAC system in the cafeteria, theater and gym; replacing pipes; making the gym usable again and replacing all the windows and doors.

The project is $746,339, or 21 percent, over budget, of which about $550,000 is earmarked for renovating the gym. The project will be funded by SPLOST III and State Capital Outlay funds and should be complete by Aug. 2, 2013.

The board will also consider Hinojosa’s recommendation for Chief Financial Officer Mike Addison’s replacement.

Addison announced on June 5 that he would be retiring after 29 years with the school district, effective Sept. 30. The district received 15 applications between then and June 19.

“We didn’t have a large quantity, but we had a good quality,” Hinojosa said. “We feel very comfortable with our recommendation.”

Hinojosa said he expects the new hire to start around Oct. 1 but would prefer him or her to come on board before Addison leaves to get familiar with the district.

Hinojosa is also recommending someone to take over as principal at Pope High School to replace Rick Beaulieu, who was named Area 6 Assistant Superintendent; and someone to serve as director of intervention and support, curriculum, instruction and assessment.

Hinojosa said the second job was created after the district realigned departments.

“We created this position from existing funds,” he said. “It’s a new position, but not additional dollars.”

Hinojosa will also recommend the board approve the retirement of Mima Carmichael, director of audit services. She has been with the district for 23 years.

The district will be accepting applications for Carmichael’s replacement until July 4. Applicants need at least eight years of accounting and/or auditing experience, and must be a certified public accountant with a bachelor’s degree in accounting. The position pays between $70,916 and $96,517 a year.
Comments
(21)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Old Educated Fool
|
June 27, 2012
SAE can always go private and show CCSD that they are far superior than CCSD are at educating our kids just like Walker school has at the OLD SPRAYBERRY HIGH SCHOOL BUILDING that was in "such" a run down state that they need a new one in 1972. Look at Walker's nice buildings even the old part from 1952.
anonymous
|
June 27, 2012
read the Audit posting again- CPA is only "preferred", you do not need one. That way they can hire the internal candidate they have chosen
believeher
|
June 27, 2012
Are you serious? Why would a district of this size allow someone that is not a CPA to be Director of Internal Audit??? I thought Addison and Hinojosa had more sense than that.
EOE
|
June 27, 2012
Does not sound like Equal Opportunity Employment if they have already chosen someone. Especially if the candidate is not qualified. Maybe HR should pay attention?
Board Responsibility
|
June 27, 2012
“If these parents feel like this is what is best for these students, I will not put myself in a position to say that the state has authority over what is best for your child,” he said. “Even though I may think it’s a mistake on their part, they have the right to do that.”

Mr Banks, do you understand the fact that ultimately as a board member you are still charged with insuring that all public school kids, including charter kids receive a quality education?? Approval and denial of charters should be void of feeling and emotion, rather it should be based on what is written in the charter application and whether the school meets its stated goals.
Charters no better
|
June 27, 2012
Charter schools despite all the hype perform worse than regular schools by most measures. It's all about the mindset of a perceived freedom from the public school bureaucracy.

After seeing how the administrators from Imagine performed at the school board hearing last year, I can see why. Other than saying their little catch phrases about how great charter schools were, there was no substance. In fact they came across very uneducated and actually copped an attitude when pressed for substantive answers. We've thrown enough taxpayer money at financial black holes that were approved just because they were minority run.
Say What?
|
June 29, 2012
Most charter schools are not "minority" run...please verify your assumptions with facts and data in the future
Sad Commentary
|
June 27, 2012
The School Board ought to do the right thing and overrule the Superintendents recommendation on the Smyrna Academy of Excellence. Unfortunately, when it comes to anything involving some governmental agency or political sub-division the operative statement is "follow the money". There should be little doubt that between Mike Addison putting the fear of death into the school administration by showing how much money it would lose, by approving the Smyrna Academy of Excellence, through the transfer of the pupil allotments for 1300 students and Judi Jones fearing competition from a charter school in that area out performing her public schools academically, it’s no wonder that they persuaded Hinojosa to deny the application. It's time Morgan, Eagle, Sweeney, and Stultz step up to the plate, show some intestinal fortitude and not simply cow tow to the Glover Street crowd. That community needs an alternative to what they are getting from our school system. Give the Smyrna Academy of Excellence an opportunity to demonstrate they can close the achievement gap
Say What?
|
June 29, 2012
A large part of Morgan's district (30168), arguably the area that needs school choice the most, is not in the primary attendance zone of the school
Announce please
|
June 27, 2012
I guess we will find out tonight who the next principal of Pope will be. I wonder when the new Kell principal will be named.
Sinking Ship?
|
June 27, 2012
How many more top level CCSD veterans are going to jump off the sinking ship "U.S.S. Hinojosa"? Alice Stouder, Mike Addison, Doug Shephard, Rob Benson, and now Mima Carmichael, all well-respected Cabinet members who left after only 1 year under the new Supt. Who's next? Step right up!
anonymous
|
June 27, 2012
How many respected staff members will leave because they are forced to work under Judi Jones?
anonymous
|
June 27, 2012
Hinojosa is a BIG GOVERNMENT school hack. He should never have been brought to Cobb County. The school board needs to bring him into check or else send him back to Texas.
Kennesaw Resident
|
June 27, 2012
@anonymous, you are absolutely right!
Say What?
|
June 29, 2012
Stop the foolishness...check his track record in Dallas...he supported and had one of the best performing charter schools in the nation...I know that he doesn't "look" like you would like him to look, but that's no reason for the baseless claims
Mad Mom
|
June 27, 2012
To mk-yes for SAE :

You need to start with directing your anger and agression toward the school board representative who has been here since before Dr. H - David Morgan. Mr. Morgan has not lived up to the standard of the board member who should be representing his Area. Vote him out. While I agree, I'm not happy with the Supt. either - Mr. Morgan has been in office longer than Hinojosa has.
Say What?
|
June 29, 2012
Most of Morgan's district was left out of the primary attendance zone in the application, so your statements do not make sense
Pure Politics
|
June 27, 2012
Disgusting that they would vote down SAE. That school is a threat to the school system. It'll put them to shame.
Suit case Jake
|
June 27, 2012
Does the Dr. Walrus know best?
mk-yes for SAE
|
June 27, 2012
A no vote would be purely political.

No thought for the students or parents.

The school board has put all their eggs(money) in the mega new smyrna elementary.

There, they can control young peoples minds!

They closed a wonderful little neighborhood school in the process, Brown Elementary!

I say go above Hinojosa's head!

Write to senators and the President!

Put your plight on ALL local news channels.

Contact Ross Cavit of WSB!

Hire an attorney!

Be LOUD!

Cobb doesn't give a rats tail about the south cobb schools!
LOL!
|
June 27, 2012
Okay, you people are funny.

"Write to the President, contact Ross Cavitt, sue, sue, sue! Give us everything, we don't care how much it costs; we want what we want!!!"

Hahahaha!

And we wonder why this country is in debt up to it's eyeballs?
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides