Lembeck: MCS staff will look into Teach for America hires at job fair
by Jon Gillooly
jgillooly@mdjonline.com
March 14, 2012 12:42 AM | 2495 views | 8 8 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA — Superintendent Dr. Emily Lembeck told the Marietta Board of Education on Tuesday she would be sending staff to check out potential hires at a job fair Teach for America is conducting later this month.

“As you know, Teach for America has been in the news lately, and I just wanted to bring you all up to date,” Lembeck said.

Lembeck was referring to media reports of Cobb Schools Superintendent Dr. Michael Hinojosa, who has come under criticism for an attempt to hire Teach for America candidates without first running it by the Cobb Board of Education.

School board Chairwoman Jill Mutimer asked Lembeck how teachers who come through the Teach for America program are different.

“The difference is they haven’t had a formal education on how to be a teacher through their college experience,” Lembeck said. “They’re students who are very, very strong students that come out and say they’re willing to teach at least a couple of years.”

They also are certified by the state as “highly qualified” and have taken the standardized test for teachers called the Georgia Assessments for the Certification of Educators.

Board member Tom Cheater asked if such teachers were prepared to take over a class on the first day of school.

“From what we understood when we met with them, they’re ready to get into a classroom,” Lembeck said.

Board member Irene Berens asked what the cost was to hire them, to which Lembeck answered that the school system would pay the Teach for America organization $8,000 each teacher over the course of two years for training. Marietta would also pay the teacher a beginning teacher’s salary.

“But we’re already paying science and math teachers a signing bonus to come and work for us: $1,000 a year for three years,” Lembeck said.

Board member Stuart Fleming gave the program a glowing endorsement.

“Teach for America I think has gotten a little bit of a bad rap based on some of the school systems across this country that they have gone into, but the actual teachers … are tremendously qualified individuals,” Fleming said. “Whether or not they’ve been trained historically as teachers is another subject, but these are from Brown, these are from Yale, these are from folks who want to make a difference in the world in which they live in and are not driven by money, so I’m fully supportive of the process and going down the path to explore it.”

Mutimer asked if such teachers only remain with the system for a few years.

“Some of them stay longer,” Lembeck said. “Some of them really choose to stay because they find that this is gratifying. For many reasons people choose to dedicate some of their early years to higher purposes in their mind. Why do people go and join the Peace Corps and stay in another country for several years? It’s just something they are deeply committed to.”

Lembeck said the organization contacted her in December and asked to meet to tell her more about the group. Lembeck said she told them at the time that Marietta rarely begins school with teacher openings, and if it does those openings are limited and specific in the areas of math, science and special education. Even so, the group invited her to attend a Teach for America job fair on March 23.

“I’ve not negotiated with them,” Lembeck said. “I’ve not committed to anything with them, but I do think it’s worth checking into.”

Mutimer said she supports the move.

“Well, we want you to hire the best teachers wherever you find them. That’s what I want,” Mutimer said.

Lembeck said she would give the board an update on what she thought of the candidates at a future board meeting.
Comments
(8)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Ms. NO NO
|
March 17, 2012
I have to agree with the poster about consideration given to those teachers that were RIF from the district. Many of those former teachers still have not found jobs. Also, please consider those staff members that have gone back to school to get certified or working on certification before looking for some "outsiders". Most of the TFA candidates stay on the job long enough to get their student loans paid back and many of them move on to lucrative corporate jobs.
Muteimer
|
March 15, 2012
Really? I would think a BOE Member would already KNOW and be fully aware of what Teach for America IS, and what it does, supports and how it operates. Ooops, your naivete is showing! If you don't know any more about this program - research it for yourself and don't rely on other people to do your homework.

TFA is NOT a great program, and what does it matter if someone is the smartest with the most degrees if they are not educated in the education field? They may not even be able to tolerate the little kiddies after their first day!

Please quit jumping on every bandwagon CO.

Why scope out TFA candidates when you just RIF'd very qualified teachers so recently??? Why not hire some of them back?

The sheer fact you have to PAY for TFA proves it's not what it's cracked up to be.

Stu - I'm surprised at your thoughts. What's happened to you?
noseriously
|
March 15, 2012
Not a good idea. For the few teachers that are hired I would rather rely on my own people to vet them out. There are experienced teachers looking for jobs.
westcobb
|
March 14, 2012
I don't understand. Why hire a person from this non qualified group and pay more money per employee instead of hiring a real teacher that graduated from college with a teaching degree and is trained to "teach". You are throwing $8000 of taxpayer money in the garbage can, then the real teachers in the can too! Hire real teachers for our children. Forget this group. They are getting experience for their resume, then leaving the kids and going out into the business world never looking back at the kids! Teachers stay teaching in an underpaid position because they love teaching the children.
Not Again
|
March 14, 2012
This move not only saves the district money (by not hiring more qualified teachers) but also allows them to continue to appear "cutting edge" by looking at alternate routes to certification. These teachers are not remotely prepared for the classroom, but MCS can work them into the dirt and the teachers won't complain because the assignment is temporary.
New Teacher
|
March 14, 2012
'This move not only saves the district money" $8k plus standard salary seems like it costs 8k more than a new teacher fresh out of school who is trained an anxious to work. Makes me feel bad for my friends who have not been able to get a job. They are not only competing for a position with the thousands of people who studied and earned an E.D., now they have to compete with TFA people.

No no no
|
March 14, 2012
Not only are these people (who are very bright, I agree) not prepared for what hits them on the first day of school but they are typically shunned by their colleagues and given the worst assignments by the principals. The whole school atmosphere is poisoned by a TFA presence. Hence, the astounding quit rate.
poor choice
|
March 14, 2012
It would be a poor choice to hire these people. The Cobb School Board was smart enough to know to stay away. Their stats are NOT glowing by any means when looking at their teaching results. So Mr. Flemming are you saying that teachers who have degrees are only in it for the money? Nice, thanks for the support. I strongly believe this is a horrible decision, they are not trained to manage a classroom, and in our district, with our students, people need to be prepared... what a waste of money, $8,000 for training... we can't buy texts but we can train people who we could hire for the same price and not train... accountibility is needed
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides