District helped charter group get $50K grant
by Lindsay Field
lfield@mdjonline.com
Jan 30, 2012 | 3645 views | 18 18 comments | 17 17 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA – Although the Cobb school district has never sought any of the $400 million from the federal Race to the Top program for its own use, district staff did help a potential charter school land a $50,000 planning grant through the program.

State Rep. Alisha Thomas Morgan (D-Austell) is one of the organizers of the proposed school, to be called the STEM Inventors Academy. Her husband, David Morgan, is vice chair of Cobb’s school board, and last fall cast the deciding vote to close another charter school in the same south Cobb area as this proposed school.

Cobb’s two leading universities, Kennesaw State and Southern Polytechnic, are both on board as partners with the proposed school, and Cobb Chamber President David Connell is among those who wrote letters on the organizers’ behalf for the grant.

On Jan. 11, the same day the STEM Academy team learned it had won the $50,000 “Venture Grant” under RTTT, organizers notified the Cobb district of their intent to seek a charter.

Jay Dillon, a spokesman for Cobb Schools, downplayed the amount of help district staff provided in the charter’s application for the federal dollars, saying district staff only met with the group once or twice.

He also said that this was the first time the district had ever been asked to help with procuring such funds, and only the second time ever that any proposed charter school had come to the district for help. (The first, he said, was in 2008 when organizers of the local aviation museum made efforts toward getting state money for a STEM charter school, but those efforts failed.)

Nathaniel Riley Jr., 35, of Mableton is one of the organizers behind the STEM Academy school. He said he asked the Cobb district last summer for the help, and he submitted the RTTT application on Nov. 1. Riley is a director at financial firm IntercontinentalExchange Inc. and a father of two. The Memphis native has one child in a Cobb elementary school and one in a private middle school, he said.

His goal with the charter school is to add options for parents in south Cobb, where test scores tend to be well below other schools in the county, highlighting a stark achievement gap.

“We love our community in Mableton. I do not know any other area we could move to with the level of racial, socioeconomic, cultural and age diversity as you can find the south Cobb area. To some, this diversity is viewed as a crutch as to why there are challenges in some of the schools. My belief is that it is this diversity that should strengthen our schools. There should be options available to parents in south Cobb who have an interest in STEM, or any other focus for that matter,” Riley said.

“In my idealistic world of schools in south Cobb, we would have a plethora of themed school options available to choose from, and personally speaking, it doesn’t matter what organizational model is used, whether it be charter, magnets or something in between. The main goal is making sure that the school leadership and the model that is used is optimized to ensure the school can be effective,” he said.

The grant money will be used to help the organizers develop a solid plan for the K-12 school they hope to open in fall 2013, though Riley declined to be more specific. The school district will serve as a “pass-through” for the grant money, which has not yet been received.

Still unknown is how many people will sit on the board of the charter school, and who those people will be; where the school will be located; and exactly how much it will cost to operate.

Besides Rep. Morgan and the Chamber’s Connell, others who wrote letters of support in the grant application were Dr. Ronald Matson, interim dean of KSU’s science and math college; James Valbrun, a partner in the Atlanta-based law firm of Wotorson, Thompson and Valbrun; Clarice Barber-Page, a 2008 candidate for the Cobb County Commission; Pastor Wilbur T. Purvis III of Destiny World Church in Austell; Darlene Duke, executive director of the Sweetwater C.A.M.P. nonprofit; and south Cobb residents Beth Lloyd, Andrea Young and Valerie Testman

Rep. Morgan announced the proposed school and its grant at a community meeting on Jan. 13, but has refused to answer further questions.

But David Morgan says he helped the charter school team connect with the school district.

“I wanted to make sure that those people were in contact with each other,” he said. “Especially if it was another opportunity to bring another school into our district.”

But most of his fellow school board members apparently knew nothing of the proposed school, or any help it was getting from district staff.

Lynnda Eagle, David Banks, Kathleen Angelucci, Tim Stultz and Alison Bartlett all said they were unaware of the partnership.

Banks, of northeast Cobb, said that he thought it was “interesting” that Morgan knew about STEM Inventors Academy when he voted in September against renewing the charter of Imagine International Academy of Mableton.

“What’s going on there?” Banks asked.

On Sept. 29, the board voted, 4-3, to close Imagine Mableton after this school year, as recommended by the superintendent. Stultz, Angelucci and Banks cast the three votes to allow it to stay open.

This week, Morgan rejected the idea that he should have recused himself from that vote, in light of his help to the STEM Academy school. At last Thursday night’s school board meeting, some public-comment speakers also chastised him for voting on the Imagine school.

“I most definitely think there was not a conflict of interest,” Morgan said. “Nothing in the world negates two quality charter schools being in the same area. If we had two start-up charters in our area that complemented each other, I could see it working. That’d be great for students, it’d be a great choice for parents.”

Without Morgan, the vote would have resulted in a 3-3 tie, meaning the school could have been allowed to continue.

Banks, one of those who voted in favor of the Imagine school, said the vote should be revisited. Stultz, another who voted for Imagine, said he too would like the board to reconsider — but only if a member of the majority would agree to put it back on the agenda.

In an email, Stultz said, “I have a desire to see it back on the agenda and would be happy to make that request, but only if a member who voted with the majority was willing to do the same.”

At this point, that looks unlikely. At least three of those in the majority say they’re not inclined to reconsider.

But Morgan said he will indeed recuse himself from any votes regarding the STEM Academy charter.

“I don’t want to muddy the waters,” he said.
Comments
(18)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Morgan has to GO
|
February 01, 2012
I sure hope the people in David Morgan's district have the sense to vote him out during the next election. He has been a do-nothing board member and now we are seeing even more information that casts a negative view on him. Wise up voting taxpayers. Our kids deserve better than this.
May Retta
|
January 31, 2012
This is the most disgusting thing that I have heard of in my more than forty years in Cobb County. Please, Mr. District Attorney, let a Grand Jury look at this!
Just Curious
|
January 31, 2012
Why hasn't the MDJ looked into Mr. Morgan's affiliation with the American Federation of Children. It is a leading national advocacy organization promoting school choice, with a specific focus on advocating for school vouchers and scholarship tax credit programs. The American Federation for Children is a 501(c)(4) organization. Isn't that in direct contradiction to his position on a PUBLIC school board.

Morgan is currently a registered lobbyist for this organization and has received over $10,000 in payment according to the Georgia State Ethics Commission.
Curious one
|
January 31, 2012
Wow, if this is factual then the Cobb School Board must take immmeidate and just and harsh action !
a Cobb citizen
|
January 30, 2012
Cobb Taxpayer, It is not Mr. Banks, but David Morgan who is the one who is vice chair and pulled all the shenanigans. Yes, he should step down and consider resigning. The vote should be revisited and Mr. Morgan should recuse himself. That would be the fair thing to do.
Sanctions
|
January 30, 2012
In addition to the BOE revisiting the vote and officially reprimanding Morgan, someone could also file a formal complaint with both SACS/AdvanceEd and the GA PSC (re: Morgan's teacher certificate). However, short of a recall election, only the Governor can actually remove Morgan.
Check your facts
|
January 31, 2012
Morgan has no teaching certificate nor leadership certificate even though he was principal for failed, KIPP/Achieve Academy. (Which is tied to Teach For America)
a Cobb citizen
|
January 30, 2012
David Morgan is talking out of both sides of his mouth when he says there is no conflict. Two charter schools in the same area would obviously be competitors for students whose parents are looking for another choice than the district school. I am actually amazed Alisha Morgan went ahead and announced that she was involved with the startup school and all this came out. Seems to me it would have been a lot smarter to have kept it under her hat for a lot longer. I am glad she did not. The other charter school deserves a chance at a fair vote. I just hope the Cobb BOE sees it that way.
Cobb Taxpayer
|
January 30, 2012
So much for the "new board" being open and transparent. They are so split it is a joke. Mr. Bank's should step down from his vice chair position and even consider resigning from the board. Asking school staff to help with the grand and stating he didn't have a conflict of interest is very questionable.

Jay Dillion should be asked to explain who directed the staff to the work and how much time did they spend. I bet we would find a lot more than what is being report. Thank you for opening our eyes to all the issues around Cobb County: Cobb EMC, Cobb Chamber, CID, Cobb Commissioners and the Cobb School Board. If I forgot someone, my apologies!!!!
Point of Order
|
January 30, 2012
Mr. Morgan is vice chair, not Banks.
ol' retired doc
|
January 30, 2012
It is absolutely essential that David Morgan resign and without hesitation or delay. What a mess this is!
Frankie58
|
January 30, 2012
Where is Brock Clay?, if Morgan in fact used his "position" as a member of the BOE, and did not advise or get that approval from the full board, is this not a violation of ethics??? It seems that there has been alot of, shall we say, covert negotiations (involving him and his wife)without the oversite of the BOE....this needs to be INVESTIGATED! As another post indicated, I too would like to see if they have any monetary involvement or gain in this endeavor......
dorthy harris
|
January 30, 2012
I guess after reading this article there is one thing that I don't understand. It seems apparent that David Morgan should have never even been allowed to be a part of this vote or even any discussion on this matter. What I don't understand is a board that is so narrow minded that even when they have been given additional information they would say they aren't inclined to reconsider. Maybe there were lying when they said they had no knowledge of the help the district gave the Morgan's charter school with the 50K grant. Maybe they are just as unethical as David Morgan and have no interest in the children of South Cobb County either.
anonymous
|
January 30, 2012
or maybe there is more to this story than meets the eye. Keep digging Lindsey!
Postmaster Marie
|
January 30, 2012
I'll bet the very first thing the students learn at the new school will be how to spell 'corruption'.
Cobb Taxpayer
|
January 30, 2012
To believe anything that the Morgan "hanky panky" duo support, particularly regarding education, is pure foolishness. Wake up Board Members and Chamber and see the obvious conflicts of interest !
anonymous
|
January 30, 2012
The Morgans have the opportunity to have monetary gain somewhere in there, guaranteed.
Reality Check
|
February 07, 2012
Let's clarify the facts: Morgan votes to close the failing Imagine Charter School. At the same time, his wife is trying to improve the education in Cobb County by helping organize a STEM school (which we really need and she does not stand to gain anything financially). Where is the corruption? Sounds like someone is actually trying to improve the education in Cobb County... why are we complaining? What is the conflict of interest? There is no financial gain in this for him. I applaud his attempts to get a STEM school started and from what I know of IIAM, it needed to be closed.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides