Immigration Reform - Only in U.S. do illegal immigrants feel entitled
November 02, 2011 12:01 AM | 2899 views | 13 13 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Can you imagine someone breaking the law by sneaking across the border into Mexico, then crying foul and filing suit against the government claiming that their “rights” had been violated? Neither can we, frankly. Only in the United States do illegal resident aliens feel such a sense of entitlement.

The latest reminder of that came courtesy of a lawsuit filed by three such illegal immigrants in federal court against Cobb County — a suit that wisely was tossed by Judge Charles Pannell Jr. of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia in an Oct. 19 ruling announced on Monday.

The three, all of whom had been arrested on various forgery, driving and shoplifting violations, sued Cobb Sheriff Neil Warren, Cobb Commission Chairman Tim Lee and others claiming their Miranda “rights” had been violated; claiming the police had illegally seized immigration documents that would have allowed them to stay here; and had denied them access to lawyers. Funny thing about that last allegation — they didn’t seem to have any trouble finding one to take their case, did they?

In essence, the three and their attorney were trying to have the federal 287(g) program employed by Cobb’s sheriff declared unconstitutional. That program allows Cobb police to hold illegal immigrants who have been arrested on other crimes and notify the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement so the lengthy deportation process can begin.

Said Warren after the ruling was announced, “In today’s society, the amnesty advocates will engage in every attempt to further their mission. Unfortunately, the Department of Homeland Security and the current Administration have continuously underfunded all immigration enforcement for many years. During these tough economic times, it is a shame that taxpayers have to fund the legal costs associated with such lawsuits.”

Indeed. In fact, those “tough economic times” have in fact been made much tougher by the presence of hordes of those who are in this country illegally and are willing to do blue-collar work for much lower wages than U.S. citizens. Equally at fault — if not more so — are the U.S. employers — a heavy percentage of them in construction and agriculture — who have hired illegal immigrants for years at close to slave wages and left taxpayers footing the bill for the education and medical costs of those illegal immigrants.

With Washington refusing to tackle the issue, and with a president and mainstream media whose sympathies are clearly on the side of the illegal immigrants rather than the law, state and local officials are taking on matters themselves. Although 287(g) is a federal program, it is local-level officials who Washington has left holding the bag. They are damned if they try to enforce the law and damned if they don’t.

The suit was not the first aimed at gutting our immigration laws and won’t be the last. But we can, at least, hope that they wind up with endings like this one.
Comments
(13)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
WestCobber
|
November 03, 2011
While Bush certainly did his share to increase the illegal problems - and don't get my wrong, I think every last one here illegally should be put on a bus and delivered back to their own country and if caught again put in detention camps. However, if it were not for your hero - probably, Lyndn Jonnson, and his Great Society, the welfare programs these people are now able to take advantage of would not exist. So there is cetainly enough blame to go around - and how does your current President feel this should be handled. I think he has done as much to encourage the hoards in 3 years as Bush did in 8.
ZOO
|
November 02, 2011
This "entitlement" mindset is a direct gift from George W. Bush. Before his cast his insanity upon the American people, there was no sitting U.S. President in memory that had stood publicly on mutilple occasions and defended invaders from Mexico. Not only did he give illegal aliens a sense of entitlement and emboldenment, his words triggered a tidal wave of illegals pouring into the U.S. that showed up in the 2010 Census. As the "father of illegal immigration", he brought us where we are today - fighting frivolous lawsuits just to enforce the law against the scum of the earth, and pondering the end days of America due to a massive invasion.
L. Trotsky
|
November 02, 2011
In Illinois, the government will supply you with a FREE cell phone and give you 250M every month.

Go ahead, google it.

This is why the IL is going broke. And let's not even begin on the IL LINK (food stamp) program.

The government unions are driving our taxes into the stratosphere; our only hope is that the Feds allow the State to go go bankrupt through some modification of bankruptcy law.
June39
|
November 02, 2011
On top of having to take their guff, we are forced to pay $113 BILLION for their upkeep. So, in effect, we're paying them to try and sue us as well as draining every facet of our society. Why is our government doing this to us? I write to all my representatives and in return, get form letters that tell me all they're doing against illegal immigration. If they were really doing something, they'd go on nationwide TV and tell illegals to get the h--- out of here or face prison time.
AdeleC
|
November 02, 2011
As long as these corrupt Corporations want consumers

at any cost we Americans will have to watch these arrogant horrid foreigners in our territory.

If ICE was allowed to do their job.

These irritants would be running back to Mexico!
Ali99999
|
November 02, 2011
NtheNo wrote on Wednesday, Nov 02 at 09:08 AM »

We know the problem - question is, how do we fix it? The entitlement mindset has been fed to a generation in exchange for political power that will ultimately lead to this country's destruction. Put best: "We are living in a sick society filled with people that would not directly steal from their neighbor but who are willing to demand that the government do it for them." (William L. Comer)

--------In the late 1990s, welfare reform was successful in a number of states at moving welfare recipients from welfare into the workforce. Of course, these programs depend on there being jobs to move them into and many of the entry-level jobs that these welfare recipients would have taken are now taken by illegal aliens. Welfare reform needs to begin by enforcing immigration laws and freeing up the lower paying jobs (and probably in the process increasing the wages these jobs pay once the illegal aliens are gone).
UnbelievablyLiberal
|
November 02, 2011
See what liberalism gets us, folks? A dependent, lazy underclass of people who are forever dependent on social programs ... and a smaller working class.
Kasandra
|
May 25, 2012
I know more immigrants that work and pay for absolutely everything they ave , than Americans. I don't know a single immigrant that has used state assistance , but I sure as hell know plenty of Americans that do. It seems to me, everyone ere is talking about things that they honestly have no clue about. Bunch of idiots, you are.
inaheapoftrouble
|
November 02, 2011
As the fifth person to post on this blog, I want to say I agree completely with the first 4 posts. We're in a heap of trouble. Our voices need to be heard. I used to be compassionate and understanding of the plight of others. Not anymore. This has made me furious at our government. Not just for the freebies to illegals, but all of the handouts to people who are able to work but aren't going to because of government assistance. How is this mess ever going to be resolved?
WestCobber
|
November 02, 2011
When I hear reports of what this so called "super committee" is looking at - it is always social security, medicare (which all working people paid into) and medicaid. There is never any mention of what it costs to feed, house, educate )including the cost of hiring special teachers for those who cannot speak English) and provide medical care to these people who put absolutely nothing back into the system (and don't give me that nonsense that they paid sales tax - big deal) except to have more children so they can claim more welfare. If they are truly just "hard working people looking for a better life" let them assimilate into this society, both with requiring they learn English within a year at the most, apply for citizenship, and pay their taxes. Why is it that social security and medicare are always on the chopping block? These are programs that were put in place and money taken from every pay check literally at the point of a gun - now many are being told this was just basically another "tax" since if they are successful the withholding taken from their pay checks is going to "redistribute the wealth". The way I understand it, billions are spent not ust by the federal government but state and local governments to take care of these illegals. Why is that not on the table - as well as the hundreds of billions that are given away to countries that hate our guts and wish only our demise? When are we going to get politicians with some common sense. If you haven't seen the movie "Dave" - get it - a real eye opener.
NtheNo
|
November 02, 2011
We know the problem - question is, how do we fix it? The entitlement mindset has been fed to a generation in exchange for political power that will ultimately lead to this country's destruction. Put best: "We are living in a sick society filled with people that would not directly steal from their neighbor but who are willing to demand that the government do it for them." (William L. Comer)
Pat H
|
November 02, 2011
The case of Jessica Colotl is the poster child for these illegal immigrants who bleed American taxpayers. Why do they feel entitled? Because they are - free education, healthcare, food stamps, housing assistance, Social Security payments and a job without paying taxes.

The entitlements are increased by having many children while being paid in cash.
Dee Mac
|
November 02, 2011
This Should be the Law of the land, why it's not concerns me greatly

*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides