Not dead yet: Officials: Reports of WellStar’s east Cobb health park’s denial greatly exaggerated
by By Katy Ruth Camp
krcamp@mdjonline.com
May 22, 2011 12:00 AM | 3575 views | 5 5 comments | 11 11 recommendations | email to a friend | print
WellStar is proposing to build a surgery center and doctors’ offices in east Cobb on this property at 3624 Providence Road.<br>Staff/Laura Moon
WellStar is proposing to build a surgery center and doctors’ offices in east Cobb on this property at 3624 Providence Road.
Staff/Laura Moon
slideshow
Joe Brywczynski, WellStar senior vice president and health parks administrator, answers questions from the crowd, which were read by facilitator Karen Hallacy, right, at a March public forum.<br>Staff/Jon-Michael Sullivan
Joe Brywczynski, WellStar senior vice president and health parks administrator, answers questions from the crowd, which were read by facilitator Karen Hallacy, right, at a March public forum.
Staff/Jon-Michael Sullivan
slideshow
A map of the area, with proposed entrances and exits.
A map of the area, with proposed entrances and exits.
slideshow
EAST COBB — WellStar Health Systems officials said Thursday that the certificate of need has not been denied for the system’s proposed $80 million, four-story health park at Providence and Roswell roads in east Cobb, even though the state health department issued what appeared to be a denial Monday.

The system was granted a certificate of need from the state Department of Community Health last September for the 20,000-square-foot outpatient surgery center it hopes to include in its plans for the nearly 188,000-square-foot health park. Current plans also call for a fitness center, nature trails and preserved green space, a sleep center, women’s center, specialists, an urgent care center, an education and wellness center and nearly 1,000 parking spaces.

But Northside Hospital has challenged that certificate, and the appeal hearing before an administrative law judge is set for Aug. 8, Joe Brywczynski, WellStar senior vice president health parks administrator, said Thursday morning before about 35 attendees during a breakfast meeting of the WellStar Health Park East Cobb Advisory Committee. The committee is providing input and suggestions to the system for architectural and structural plans for the facility.

And although the state said in its public list of permits that have been denied that the system’s certificate was denied Monday for the surgery center, WellStar Director of Strategic Planning Caroline Aultman said it was only a “what if” decision by the judge to be used for the appeal hearing and has no bearing on the outcome of the appeal.

“This CON (that was approved) was filed stating that the ambulatory surgery center at the East Cobb Health Park would be an extension of WellStar Windy Hill Hospital and that ambulatory surgery rules did not apply to this filing,” Aultman said. “This is because WellStar is shifting outpatient operating rooms from WellStar Windy Hill Hospital to the East Cobb Health Park. Thus, there is not a net increase in the number of outpatient operating rooms in this geographic area. The state approved this CON application and agreed that the ambulatory surgery center rules did not apply.”

Before the original appeal hearing that was scheduled for April, the assigned hearing officer determined that he needed additional information about the project and issued a remand order requesting that the state give its stance as to how the application would have fared if the ambulatory surgery center rules applied, Aultman said.

“In this hypothetical scenario, the DCH stated that a CON application would have been denied,” Aultman said. “The hearing officer made it clear in his remand order that all current filings would remain intact and would not be impacted by this supplemental decision. The original approval from the DCH is still in effect.”

What is still not clear, however, is whether the system will go through the normal zoning process with the county Board of Commissioners or through the Hospital Authority. If WellStar goes through the Hospital Authority, it avoids measures such as commission stipulations and resident input that are allowed through the zoning process.

When Cobb Planning and Zoning Commission member Mike Terry posed the question to Brywczynski, saying, “It sounds as though you have already made up your minds,” Brywczynski stood by his claim that WellStar has not yet determined its avenue of permitting.

Brywczynski said the company is still on target for beginning construction in March 2012 and to serve its first clients in Aug. 2013. WellStar spokesman Keith Bowermaster said that the system has had several public input meetings, and that as people understand the potential plans for the development, they are more supportive of the complex. And even if the certificate is ultimately denied, Bowermaster said the system can still build the complex, but the 20,000 square feet under contention for the surgery center would have to be filled with something else. So no matter what, Bowermaster said, the complex will be built.

“Our meetings are becoming more and more positive,” Bowermaster said. “The (East Cobb Civic Association) meeting dispelled a lot of rumors and our public support has increased. We are a community asset, and work with our neighbors to make sure we are all happy. There are not too many opportunities where a group can comment on the layout and architectural design of a building that will be going up.”

Also in attendance Thursday were commissioners Bob Ott and JoAnn Birrell, former Commissioner Thea Powell and Cobb Planning and Zoning Commission member Christi Trombetti.
Comments
(5)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Local resident
|
July 12, 2011
Will we be remembered as the people who blighted yet another residential area with unabashed corporate greed? Do you think the County will let me build a comparable, multistory complex in a residential zone? Remind me again why this is so? Why do you even have zoning if it's so easily ignored? Wellstar has spit in the face of local residents. This going through will make a permanent memorial to that insult. I hear that an entrance on Providence "isn't planned"? They will do it anyway, whining later that they need it. Mark my words.
He said What?!?
|
May 23, 2011
"There are not too many opportunities where a group can comment on ...a building going up."

REALLY? Virtually every other planned building goes through public zoning, and has EVERY need and opportunity to have public safety and neighborhood concerns addressed.

Wellstar is bamboozling the CON process and making obscene gestures to the community by not allowing for elected officials or residents' rights to be protected.

He says as much in the article, "...even if the certificate is denied...the complex will be built". If that isn't a snub at the Board of Health I don't know what is.

And I am quite sure that his perception that the neighbors are happy is equally out of touch with reality. Arrogance like this only inflames our concerns!
ECCA Lies
|
May 23, 2011
Why is ECCA playing "lap dog" to Wellstar? This proves that ECCA is irrelevant to East Cobb residents.

ECCA should have represented the truth about this development. It would never be considered inside a residential area if it weren't for the GA Department of Community Health.
Unsatisfied Neighbor
|
May 23, 2011
If Wellstar wants to get the neighbors off their back, they can STOP BEING so adverserial.

The ECCA is NOT representative of neigbors interests(as is obvious from the meetings) , and any meeting that does not result in Wellstar guaranteeing the integrity of Providence Road AND complying with zoning due process is UNACCEPTABLE.

PR and spin do not substitute for being a good corporate citizen and neighbor.
Federal $$$ Used?
|
May 23, 2011
With all this selling of "green" everything on this project, are federal dollars being used for this project???
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides