On condition of anonymity
by Kim Isaza
News Editor
April 27, 2011 03:17 PM | 4445 views | 6 6 comments | 17 17 recommendations | email to a friend | print
I get lots of anonymous letters, some helpful, a few cryptic, some interesting. I do my best to check out allegations contained in them, but if the “target” of the letter insists nothing is amiss, there’s not much for me to go on. I understand why a whistleblower would not want to sign his or her name – but without someone willing to stand behind their allegations, they lose most of their credibility.



Here’s a letter I received this week by snail mail, how I followed up on it, and what I found out. I got no other calls or similar complaints about the issue.

“On April 11th the practice gym at Kell HS was stripped. The next day the floor was sealed with a toxin-level-four substance. Students and teachers had to breathe those toxins all week. The next week the main gym floor was stripped and sealed with the same toxin substance. This environmentally contaminated environment was forced upon everyone. Over these days the whole school was affected by the poison. No arrangements were made to make students safe.

“Students were forced to sit in classrooms and breathe poison. Students with asthma, respiratory problems and other problems suffered a lot. A little English teacher, who is pregnant, asked the nurse if her unborn baby was safe. Teachers down the English hall were sick, had headaches and felt ill. One went to the emergency room. The teacher right outside the practice gym’s door is recovering from cancer and went to the nurse. There are several teachers recovering from cancer on the English hall area. Students stayed home sick. Parents were not informed.

“The sealing process needed to be done without students and teachers and the trash was just thrown out, not according to hazardous disposal standards. Cobb County is said to have saved $4,000 by doing it now.

“This is wrong. How did this happen? Talking to the school nurse, the custodian, all the students who missed school with mystery illnesses. This is a big concern in the community.”

The Cobb County School District does not allow its employees to talk to the press about anything with even the slightest hint of controversy, and I knew a call to Kell’s principal would only route me back to district spokesman Jay Dillon, so I emailed Jay a list of questions – were the floors indeed stripped? By whom? On the days noted in the letter? Were parents notified? Were classes moved?

Here is Jay’s response, emailed later the same day I asked:

“I'm not sure who sent you this email but it has certainly overstated the facts, to say the least. The school hired an outside contractor, Stevens Gymnasiums, to refinish the gym floor. The floor was sanded, then coated with polyurethane, then painted, then coated with polyurethane again. The process takes several days, and the company worked at night and on the weekend. Obviously, the polyurethane creates a smell so the gym's exhaust fans ran constantly throughout the process. For the main building near the gym, outside hallway doors were opened and fans were set up. Also, all classrooms near the gym were relocated. So, precautions were definitely taken. This is the same gym floor refinishing process we use at all schools. The smell is an inconvenience, but not a health hazard. According to Ms. Donovan, one student with asthma reported discomfort, and another student reported a headache. That's it. Just two students out of 1,688 reported any effects that could be attributed to the gym refinishing. She said she was not aware of any teachers who reported feeling ill, and certainly not any who went to the emergency room. The company placed the empty polyurethane cans in the dumpster, which is proper disposal.”

I’ve also put in a call to school board member Kathy Angelucci to see if she’s heard of any complaints at this school, which is in her district. Did anyone else out there take issue with this at Kell?
Comments
(6)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Beretverde
|
July 07, 2011
Didn't an anonymous blogger/writer put the spotlight on former Cobb County Public Safety Director Mickey Lloyd? Whistle-blowing at its finest, for one of Cobb's finest!
okpeople
|
July 05, 2011
The anonymous complainer was probably a contractor who lost the bid on refinishing the floors. Its very cutthroat in the world of bid wars.
Cobb Teacher
|
July 01, 2011
But how do we alert the parents and public to a school safety issue while protecting our own livelihood as teachers? To my knowledge, no whilstleblower law will force a school to renew my contract. I might be protected for a year, but if we're in the midst of budget cuts, I could easily be dismissed with minimal legal risk to the county. I need a way to out dangerous information backing it up with my position, but without endangering my family. I have tried this many times through the county, through the GHSA, and through the professional standards commission. No one can provide guarantees. As much as I feel information needs to get out; how can I do so with the sword of Damocles hanging over me?
Anonymous Abraham
|
July 01, 2011
I want to blow the whistle on a former employer for the same kind of toxic exposures. And they leaked sensitive data on clients for a few weeks before the security hole was patched. Problem is, folks do not like whistle-blowers these days, because they make people uncomfortable.

There was another nasty security hole where financial transactions could have been made without any authorization, to individuals overseas, and after I complained, my career started doing the old nose-dive reserved for... Whistle-blowers!

People need to get over themselves and get REAL. What happened to 1950s America? I miss it! I sorely miss the days of Andy Griffith and the Honest FBI and real police officers who CARED if someone was stolen from.

Now we have teeny-agers who demand payment for stolen goods, saying that some thing left behind by accident was stolen "fair and square."

Bring America BACK to the days where people felt no fear of complaining about wrong-doings!
semi-anonymous
|
May 07, 2011
I tend to agree, but apply the transparency to the editorial page as well! Whoever actually pens the editorials (including the mean-spirited, at times, Around Town) should be made known. If you believe what you write, own up to it!
Oliver G. Halle
|
April 27, 2011
This is a good example of why the MDJ should not allow anonymous bloggers. As for anonymous letter writers, unless they provide corrobative details that a reporter can check on without too much effort, they shouldn't be taken seriously. Without knowing who bloggers or wrtiers are it's almost impossible to determine what might be their hidden agenda. In the instance you cite at Kell, could the writer have been a disgruntled teacher, student, parent--someone out to embarrass or undermine the principal? Who knows? Great column. Now convince Mr. Brumby to put an end to the anonymous bloggers who hide behind cover (or under rocks) to make some of the most mean-spirited comments.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides