Library patrons throw the book at Lee's plan
by Kim Isaza
newseditor@mdjonline.com
April 09, 2011 12:00 AM | 8963 views | 63 63 comments | 43 43 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Margaret Johnson-Hodge of Kennesaw, a national best-selling author, says of the proposal to close 13 libraries: ‘A society that doesn’t have adequate libraries is denying itself a viable future.’<br>Staff/Jon-Michael Sullivan
Margaret Johnson-Hodge of Kennesaw, a national best-selling author, says of the proposal to close 13 libraries: ‘A society that doesn’t have adequate libraries is denying itself a viable future.’
Staff/Jon-Michael Sullivan
slideshow
EAST COBB - As news that most of the county's libraries may be forced to close their doors in as little as three weeks sunk in on Friday, the reaction was not good.

"What did we do to be left with nothing?" asked east Cobb Commissioner Bob Ott, whose district stands to lose all of its libraries. "It's not fair to the citizens of District 2 to have nothing as a result of this proposal. They pay the same taxes as everyone else in this county."

The proposal for closing the immediate, $31 million budget hole was made public Thursday afternoon by County Chairman Tim Lee. It includes a property tax increase to shore up the fire fund, and across-the-board cuts of 3.5 percent in the county budget.

Of the county's 17 libraries, only the four regional libraries would stay open. Those are the Central Library, near the Marietta Square; Mountain View, on Sandy Plains Road near Shallowford Road; South Cobb, in Mableton; and West Cobb, off of Mars Hill Road.

Three senior centers, in north Cobb and Smyrna, would also close, as would some outdoor swimming pools.

In Ott's district, the idea of closing the new East Cobb Library had plenty of people scratching their heads. There is no regional library in that part of the county.

But closing the library, which has been open just over a year, will still cost the county. The county leases the 16,864-square-foot space in the Parkaire Landing shopping center for about $168,000 per year under a 20-year lease. Breaking that lease, which requires six months' notice, and repaying a remodeling credit granted by the landlord will cost the county about $500,000.

Shadi Fahadan, 34, who is pregnant with her second child, said she visits the East Cobb Library at least once each week. She also volunteers there.

"Library resources have been good for my daughter. She's a good reader now," Fahadan said of her child, who is in pre-kindergarten. "The only reason was bringing her to the story time every week. I was planning to bring another once to the story time," she said, rubbing her belly.

She hasn't told her daughter yet that the library will likely be closing.

"She's going to be very sad," Fahadan said. She lives near the East Cobb Library, and the Mountain View library, while nice, is much further from her home.

"I can't go there as much as I come here," she said. "It's too far."

Mary Dehaye also lives near the East Cobb Library, which she said is "very popular."

"It's one of the few benefits you see from taxes," Dehaye said. "Everybody has access to a library. It makes me angry" that it could be closed, she said.

The county is continuing to receive comments via email and its website about the budget cuts, and county spokesman Robert Quigley said that through noon on Friday, more than 700 emails and hundreds of phone calls have come in. The email address is budgetcomments@cobbcounty.org.

Meanwhile, a "Save Cobb Libraries" page cropped up Friday on Facebook.

The county also leases space for the Sweetwater Valley Library, in Austell's Threadmill Complex. That lease costs about $1,000 per month, and county officials were unsure on Friday of the terms to end that lease, Quigley said.

The Kennesaw Library, where Sheryl Manley leads a book discussion group, is another branch that may close.

"I'm just horrified that the people who use these computers to look for jobs won't have the access," said Manley, of Marietta.

On Thursday morning, Kennesaw Library worker Teresa Sutton received her 15-year service plaque.

"And in the afternoon, we got the news that they were closing a majority of the libraries," Sutton said. "I know we help people. I see it every single day."

Former county commissioner Thea Powell said Lee's budget recommendations don't seem "particularly thoughtful as the impact on the community."

"By doing this broad-brush, you've essentially ignored a significant portion of your population, because they are not equally distributed among the districts," Powell said.

Larry Savage, who unsuccessfully challenged Lee last year in the race for chairman, said these cuts won't solve the problem.

"We don't have a five-month problem, we have a five-year problem," Savage said. Unless the county figures out its needs for a longer term, "we're going to have to revisit this every few months."

"Then people are constantly in fear of the future, and there's always going to be another shoe to drop," Savage said.

If the cuts are approved during Tuesday's commission meeting, the closures would take effect on May 1. It seems likely that the four libraries left open would see heavier traffic, meaning longer waits for things like computers.

Gill Evert, of Marietta, was reading a magazine Friday morning at the Central Library, on Roswell Street in Marietta.

"The library is such a valuable resource of free information in one building along with computer access," Evert said. "I'm a big fan of the library, but at the same time I understand the budget. You can't buy what you can't afford, and that is what we have done with this budget."

Mary Smith, of Marietta, was reading with her children at Central Library on Friday.

"My kids are all avid readers and I would like to continue to promote that," she said. "It's just not affordable to go out and buy books."

Central Library employee Beth Silzle, who has worked for the county's library system for seven years, said no one saw the closures coming.

"We knew that furlough days were a possibility. We knew that reducing hours - again - was a possibility. We had no idea that closing 13 libraries was a possibility," Silzle said. Staff learned of the closings in a meeting Thursday afternoon.

"The director called all the branches in tears," she said.

Jon-Michael Sullivan and Erin Gray contributed to this story.
Comments
(63)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Maxine Huff
|
April 14, 2011
You are right that blood is on Sam Olens' hands, as he was Chairman during several fire and general fund millage rate decreses. however, the one poster who noted this forgot one other person....Bill Byrne. The downward shift in millage rates also was voted in on his watch. The reductions started about 10 years ago.

Why none of them but Helen Goreham have the guts to admit it's time to readjust them back up just disgusts me. You get what you pay for. Now get ready for downgrading of ISO rating, increase in homeowners insurance rates, increased response time of police, ems and fire, etc. Shame on all of you. You cant get something for nothing- and don't take your anger in the state and federal government out on your local government. We are all disgusted by them and some antics here on the local level (mulegate, dumptrucks, nepotism, the public safety and ema director scandals to name a few)

But to resist a slight shift back up in the fire tax and general fund rates will hurt all of us.
GeneralPublic
|
April 14, 2011
I don't know anyone that uses the library anymore...haven't been myself in 18 years. I am tired of paying for crap I don't use. Leave my taxes alone and find a different job!
concerned south cobb
|
April 12, 2011
To you anonymous: That was my point exactly!!!

It is the counties responsibility to enforce county ordinances and see that the county is maintained in a clean, healthy manner. My yard was cleaned up immediately after the flood, unfortunatly we still live in an area that looks like a "dead zone" due to the fact that the county does not enforce that these property owners clean their mess up. I believe that's what I said in my first comment.
anonymous
|
April 12, 2011
Why is it the government's job to clean up your yard?
just wondering?
|
April 12, 2011
I can't understand why no one is questioning or reporting on the fact that Sam Olens again, managed to get nice salary increases for "certain' elected officials before he left, which are the same ones that have received increases every year. At the same time they were discussing possible furloughs for all other county employees.Most of these elected officials are paid well in excess of their worth. Maybe you should consider having them punch a clock and paying them by the hour too!!! Why not consider reqeusting the salaries of these elected officials be adjusted back... someone made a really big mistake on that one!!!!!
concerned south cobb
|
April 12, 2011
Of course they will look to the South Cobb area to cut all they possibly can. Just look at our defaced community now that was hit by floods over a yr. and a half ago, still homes with garbage all across the front yards (right next to the elementary school on Ewing Rd), no clean up efforts have been made by the county nor have they enforced their duties to property owners to clean this mess up!!!!! Just take a look at the job the Mayor of Austell did there-that little town was put back together quickly and really receieved a fine face lift! So just go ahead and try to take more from this community.... you will hear our voices loud and clear Sir.
Ella Mentary
|
April 12, 2011
Notice that the period of deciding how to spend surplus occurred under Sam Olens' tenure as Chairman.Although he is not sitting on the Commission today, he CREATED this situation by not accruing for future needs.

Mr. Lee, this is following, not leading. You ran on a platform of "Serious Leadership". Show us some leadership. Seriously.
Jimbo Galt
|
April 11, 2011
@givemeliberty: 90% of all households have a computer, 10% of the population uses something that everyone pays for, and 100% of statistics quoted on the internet are made up on the spot.
ECW2
|
April 11, 2011
Hey Givemeliberty,

Give me a break! The library system circulated 4.2 MILLION items last year. Yes MILLION! That's books, DVDs, music and language CDs, magazines, Georgia Park Passes, etc. Cobb County also had THE HIGHEST PUBLIC COMPUTER USAGE IN GEORGIA! The highest! So, sure, for someone who has no interest in books, movies, languages, music, free community meeting spaces, study rooms, children story times, or free internet access libraries are probably obsolete. For the rest of us who leave our homes and remain curious about life and the world around us the library is seeing more use now than it ever has.

anonymous
|
April 11, 2011
Kennesaw Voter ..Why don't you move to Fulton County where you can find out first hand what it is like to live in a county with all the cuts you propose. If cuts must be made let it be with intelligent thought and purpose, not with an iron fist.
Cobb in the minority
|
April 11, 2011
This is typical Cobb county. The comments made here by people who are disappointed are same people that voted these morons into office. The people who are now complaining about the CCSD calendar are the same people who voted for the school board members. You say you want small government and then you complain about the government you put in office. You complain about "some" getting "handouts" but then you act appalled when you realize that your middle class life is not as important to your elected government officials as you thought it was when you realize you don't make enought money for them to give you a tax break. Well guess what?! If you aren't in the top 15% you can expect things to get a whole lot worse for YOU! Libraries are just the beginning.
Frugal Cobb Citizen
|
April 11, 2011
While I agree libraries serve a good purpose, I do not agree that Cobb County needs 17 libraries. Many other metro counties have far fewer libraries.

I say 4 libraries is plenty.

While we're at it, CCT needs to go.

Internet service can be as low as $14 per month. Save the gas money or bus fare you paid to get to the library to use their taxpayer funded internet to pay for your own private internet.
threeu's
|
April 11, 2011
Kennesaw Voter, I must say that you've got a mind like a steel trap. Only in your case it's rusted shut. All you seem to be able to do is either spread utter nonsense such as how Cobb County employees get 12 weeks of vacation each year or say cut, cut, cut or whine about high taxes. If you were to bother to look into it (which you can do at the library), you would find that Cobb taxes are rather low compared to metro area, especially when you consider the level of services offered. You may want to live in a county with the lowest of tax rates and a lack services, but the majority of people that moved to Cobb County don't. There are plenty out there that offer a lower level of services, a whole lot fewer that offer a lower tax rate. By the way, last time I checked I was still a property owner and not a renter despite your inane statement to the contrary.

As for givemeliberty, if you really believe that libraries no longer serve any purpose it is obvious that have both no idea how the modern library works or how to use it. Perhaps you should take some time and learn.
Carol Harless
|
April 11, 2011
WOW- National Library Week and everyone is talking about East Cobb Library closing. The library should be preparing for the summer reading programs and meeting the needs of the community. I stood outside of the East Cobb Library this afternoon and people pulled over in their cars to sign a petition to keep the library. How about trying some less evasive remedies first: furloughs, higher fines, fees for rentals and computer time, fee for yearly membership cards. What about the $1.6 million Whole Foods paid the county to move out of Merchants Walk and $500,000 paid to the county from Parkaire towards renovations for the new library? And, the cost of breaking a lease and paying back Parkaire. This new library- the newest in the system is busier than ever. It has brought revenue to Parkaire and is the community. Books enable those to take a step to another place and travel when they cannot or learn something new. If people think that computer access is all one needs. Step into the East Cobb library and see people browsing the shelves, reading a newspaper, checking out consumer reports or listening to a story in the children's section. There would be no library facility in our area/District 2 while all the other districts would have at least one. We pay taxes like everyone else in Cobb, so how about we continue to have those services. A library is not a luxury item- it is a necessity for growing of the mind .
Andrew Carnegie
|
April 11, 2011
"There is not such a cradle of democracy upon the earth as the Free Public Library, this republic of letters, where neither rank, office, nor wealth receives the slightest consideration."
alli d
|
April 11, 2011
Dear Friends,

Cobb County Commissioners are seeking public comments on balancing the 2011 budget. To balance the budget, 13 libraries are proposed to be

closed. Please take this opportunity to share your comments on balancing the budget and the

proposed closing of 13 libraries. The Board of Commissioners will vote on the proposed budget cuts on Tuesday, April 12 at 9:00 AM.

Please email comments to

BudgetComments@cobbcounty.org or visit the county website at http://www.cobbcounty.org and leave you comments under "Comments Sought on 2011 Budget."

Peter Coupe
|
April 11, 2011
We have been residents of E. Cobb for 23 years and have always appreciated what a wonderful resource we have in our libraries, In reviewing comments made regarding the potential closing of 13 library branches, I am amazed at how some are so negative and how short sighted people can be. I agree that we need to cut back expenses but it needs to be done with a scapel not a meat axe! Surely a better more thoughtful plan can be put forth which could include cutting back hours, reducing salaried personnel and promoting more library volunteers. There are enough seniors (myself included) who would be happy to put in a few hours each week as volunteers. Maybe some of the lesser utilized branches could be closed. Lets get creative!
otter357
|
April 11, 2011
Mr. Tim Lee, I shall never again vote for you.
givemeliberty
|
April 11, 2011
Libraries no longer serve any purpose whatsoever. Nearly 90% of all households have at least one computer and every student in Cobb has access to computers in school. I am amazed at the people who are all ready to cut programs other than those they "love and use". Dare say, about 10% of the population uses something that everyone pays for. This ought to be just the beginning of cuts and eliminations of programs that will get this silly government back to providing the basic of services. You want a library, then raise the money from your friends and build one that I don't have to pay for!
Kennesaw Voter
|
April 11, 2011
Libraries are a luxury item....period.

When times get tough...CUT the luxury items

When times get tough...CUT spending in all departments including police, fire, and all the rest of them.

The people who are yelling for a millage increase...aka a tax increase have got to be renters...because property owners are tired of being abused with high taxes...

CUT SPENDING! NOW!!
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides