Sick over rising health care costs
by Katy Ruth Camp
krcamp@mdjonline.com
Nov 06, 2010 | 3178 views | 20 20 comments | 12 12 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Retired Cobb County School District educator Sandy Arroyo looks through his copy of the Retiree Decision Guide 2011 at his Kennesaw home. <br> Photo by Laura Moon
Retired Cobb County School District educator Sandy Arroyo looks through his copy of the Retiree Decision Guide 2011 at his Kennesaw home.
Photo by Laura Moon
slideshow
Just two years ago, Sandy Arroyo, 64, of Kennesaw, a retired Cobb County high school teacher, was paying $340 a month for health insurance for him and his wife. Today, the couple are bracing themselves for Jan. 1 — when their coverage will cost them $620 each month.

"It doesn't make sense," Arroyo said of his 82 percent cost increase. "They're driving people away from insurance, instead of towards it. Our insurance has increased dramatically every year, and no one seems to have any answers."

Arroyo said he was shocked and confused when he received a flier a few weeks ago indicating his wife will soon be charged an additional $50 per month as a "spousal surcharge" because his wife, a nurse in the WellStar Health System, elected not to take the insurance package her company offered and instead joined her husband's United Healthcare plan.

He called United for more information, and sure enough, they told him the fee would start in January because his wife had declined her own employer's insurance, he said.

David Bottoms, vice president of the Bottoms Group, a benefits consulting firm in Marietta, said more health insurers will be charging spousal fees in the future, as it often costs companies more to take on an added dependent than it would for the spouse to enroll in group health insurance offered by his or her own employer. Bottoms said the surcharge only applies when a spouse declines other insurance for which they are eligible.

Tobacco surcharges, and even obesity surcharges are also growing in popularity among large companies trying to hold down their insurance costs, he said.

Bottoms said that the average health insurance plan will cost 12 to 15 percent more next year - and that some initiatives in the federal healthcare reform act will add another two percent cost increase.

"The federal healthcare reform didn't really accomplish the goal of lowering healthcare costs, because they'll actually go up. But there will be expanded eligibility and expansion of coverage, and it's just going to cost more because there are more benefits," Bottoms said. "There will be a lot of government subsidies to lower the costs to individuals who qualify at a certain income level. And right now it just results in a two percent increase - the bulk of the increases are coming from the insurance companies. But once it gets to 2014 and all of the healthcare reform initiatives are implemented, all bets are off."

Some changes took effect in September, six months after President Barack Obama signed the healthcare bill into law. Those changes include allowing individuals to stay on a parent's insurance through age 26 and regardless of student status; prohibiting exclusions of preexisting conditions for children; and removal of caps on lifetime benefits.

Prohibiting preexisting-condition exclusions on children's insurance puts greater risk on health insurers, Bottoms said, and most carriers simply stopped writing individual health policies for children last spring.

Bottoms attributed the rising health insurance costs to medical advances - and litigation.

For one, doctors order multiple tests, in part to avoid liability lawsuits if a disease is not caught. Prescriptions are also expensive, adding to an insurer's cost.

Bottoms also said that although residents can choose to keep their insurance plans, they lose that grandfathered status if they change insurance carriers or if an employer makes many changes to the plan.

"It's going to be hard to keep that same plan long-term, because some of the things like benefit extensions or benefit caps are going to happen regardless," Bottoms said.

Bottom line, Bottoms said, costs will go up, even though most are not a result of federal healthcare reform - yet.

"Sometimes you'd think they'd just let you keep what you have and not charge you more, but they don't give you that option," Arroyo said. "Eventually, I'm afraid it's going to get to the point where no one can afford health insurance."
Comments
(20)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
cowboy joe
|
November 08, 2010
Mike Jones in the last ten years of the Bush tax cuts the country has run up a deficit of trillions of dollars, the disparity of wealth between the top one percent and the bottom ninety nine percent has widened and the country has faced a new depression. So how is that "trickel downie" working for ya?
wonderin
|
November 08, 2010
The Republican Party pouted and sat on its hands during the entire health care debate while the bill was gutted by conservative blue dog democrats. As long as corporate interests and their stockholders are paramount in this country the average American will suffer. The health care bill doesn't even take effect until 2014. Now the Republicans want to repeal it and replace it with what? Nothing.
Pam J
|
November 07, 2010
I didn't think the healthcare plan had taken affect yet. If it has, then why are the Republications vowing to rip it apart? Rising health care costs and the inability to get affordable insurance if you are unemployed is a good reason to have some sort of federal health plan in effect. Of course our new incoming House and the President are never going to see eye to eye, so I don't expect anything good to happen. I honestly don't know when this county (Cobb) turned Republican.
lovehc
|
November 07, 2010
it all "obama's" fault and "Mr Boenher" and the new congress will fix that. Just don't die too quickly to see the change. They will repeal obamacare. But the prices will still go up. just watch
anonymous
|
November 07, 2010
Does anybody even read the articles? Only 2% of the increase is due to healthcare reform..and at least you get more coverage for that 2%. The rest is the same thing we have been getting every year from the insurance companies.....increased charges in order to increase their profits. It astounds me that people are blaming healthcare reform! United Healthcare is a private company and they are deciding on the co-pay for spouses, not the federal government. Turn off Fox News and put the blame where it belongs!!!
Painful
|
November 07, 2010
I'm in a similar position but I can assure you if you track this kind of stuff you'll notice one thing, costs go up until you hit 65! Then guess what? You're eligible for medicare. Then your primary becomes your secondary and your costs plummet. Believe me, they don't care about you. It's about their bottom line. It's not personal, it's just business. Obama care did nothing to help with that. It made it worse in the long run...
Timus
|
November 07, 2010
Hmmm. Where are all of the comments regarding this story? Hello hello hello(echo)...."Socialism" not sounding so bad now huh? Let's toss the health care reform so we can see how bad it can really get!!!
Disappointed Also
|
November 07, 2010
I am insured under the State Merit System and it is very depressing to see the rise of our insurance premiums. A lot of my co-workers, including myself, have insurance but are unable to afford the rediculous copays. The state merit insurance premiums are increasing and the copays are go up 45.00 per visit on January 1st, even to see your primary care physician. Generic medications are even increasing to $20 as of July 1st. This is rediculous. You would think the State would want to take better care of their employees. Yes, we do have coverage, but we can't afford to use it. The only time this our insurance would benefit us is if we have a major medical problem, and even then, you end up with very large deductibles and copays. In addition, the State has not given their employees raises in three years. At least if we had a raise, it would off set the rise in premiums. And people want to know why citizens of Georgia did not want to vote.
ATF
|
November 07, 2010
A surcharge on a spouse joining an employees health plan is not unusual in the business world, when the spouse has coverage available from his/her own employer.

Think about it folks. If the wife works for WellStar and doesn't take insurance, WellStar's insurance plan pays less but the retiree's insurance pays more. What that means is all WellStar and WellStar employees have lower claims experience and pay less for their insurance. The retirees and the retirees' health care plan must pay more because retirees health plan must cover the costs of the spouse's health care.

Someone pays.

Why should WellStar get off the hook for paying for health insurance for its own employee?

It gets even more interesting. Some employers actually give a bonus to employees who do not put their spouses on their employers health plan.

DebVA
|
November 07, 2010
I'm puzzled at the $620 figure quoted for the premium. I just finished enrolling for family coverage in the UHC HRA category (second most expensive premium structure) and the total is $308, which includes an $80 per month tobacco use surcharge. Nowhere in the state's booklet did I see evidence that two spousal surcharges would incur; only one, if your spouse refused his or her work coverage. Perhaps the author could clarify?
The Real World
|
November 07, 2010
You can thank the Republicans in this country for this. They refused to vote for the original Health Care proposal. Now they are going to try and cancel the little progress we have made as a country. As

Republicans, be careful what you wish for, you may

get more than you ever wanted.
toldya
|
November 07, 2010
Yep, it's about to be cheaper for companies and individuals to pay a penality than to buy insurance. It is a great way to pay off the government's huge debt with all of the penalities about to be paid. If we rack up huge medical bills without the insurance; we can just file for bankruptcy. If that isn't the problem solved I don't know what is - Can't wait for 2012!!!!
Mike Jones
|
November 07, 2010
How's that "Change you can believe in" working out for you
Tim L
|
November 07, 2010
So, this wonderful healthcare bill...that no one read...yet many loved, is gonna force working and retired people to pay for those who are not working? If this is a 'newsflash' to anyone out there, you were living in a dream world. D'OH!!

OK, those we just elected, you promised to fight this. You had better put up a good fight.
wonderin
|
November 07, 2010
So sorry Mr. & Ms. Arroyo but this is America the only industrial country with a "for profit" health care system. Their responsibility is not to you but to their executives and stockholders. The ex-CEO of your insurance company United Healthcare Stephen Hemsley received a base salary of $1.3 million in 2008 to go along with a non-equity incentive plan just over $1.8 million and additional compensation of $119,000. Thank you Mr. Arroyo! Don't look to your favorite politician for relief until you check to see how much their campaigns received from insurance companys and other special interests. Unfortunately Mr. Arroyo in this country you and I just don't count.
hmarty
|
November 07, 2010
No truer words spoken:

"Sometimes you'd think they'd just let you keep what you have and not charge you more, but they don't give you that option," Arroyo said. "Eventually, I'm afraid it's going to get to the point where no one can afford health insurance."

That was their plan from the beginning! The Federal Government wants us all to become dependent! Many of us saw this one coming, it's a crying shame what has happened to this Nation.
Thanks Nobama
|
November 07, 2010
All of those Obama supporters who are freeloaders are excited, because those of us who work hard will get screwed. We are paying for all the people who do not have insurance. I am a teacher as well and it is ridiculous the amount of money we are paying. The co-pay is now $ 45.00 per visit on top of the $ 300 per month premium. It is getting to the point that it would be better to not have insurance, and tell the hospital and doctors I have no insurance like all these others. I am disgusted by the misleading information the Obama administration handed out tat our rates would be more affordable!
debvar87
|
November 07, 2010
My husband is a retired Cobb County teacher; we are grateful for a decent pension and good healthcare benefits from the State of GA. Nevertheless, the $117 per month increase in our health insurance premium is a significant whack at a fixed income budget. From the descriptions of what awaits us and many others in 2014, costs may eventually swallow us whole. I didn't believe for a minute the propaganda last winter about healthcare costs being lowered! Wish I could suggest a solution; will have to put my faith in Mr. Boehner & the new Congress.
Sandy Arroyo
|
November 07, 2010
I would like to make a correction. My insurance rate went from $240.00 per month to $310.15 per month (including a $50.00 per month spousal surcharge). They also increases deductibles, specialist office visit co-pays, out-of-pocket maximums and pharmacy co-pays. In essence we are pay a great deal more.
anonymous
|
November 07, 2010
$620 each month? He'd better go back to being an obnoxious history teacher.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides