Diplomas delayed for some students
by Lindsay Field
May 25, 2012 12:58 AM | 3529 views | 9 9 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
SMYRNA — After twice failing the math graduation test, Campbell High Senior Shaianne Payne won’t be walking across the stage with her classmates during Saturday’s graduation ceremony. But Pomp and Circumstance will ultimately play for her and perhaps dozens of other Cobb students, if they complete graduation requirements later this summer.

Both Shaianne and her mother, Shena Lamusta, pleaded during recent school board meetings for some kind of consideration. The family says Shaianne passed all of her classes at Campbell and earned more than enough credits to graduate. The second time she took the math test, she came within three points of passing, she said.

Across Georgia, students must earn enough credits to graduate, and also must pass a graduation test in each of four core subjects — math, English, science and social studies — to get a diploma. And since at least 2002, Cobb Schools has had a policy that prohibits students who haven’t met all of those graduation requirements from participating in their class ceremony.

Cobb schools spokesman Doug Goodwin said district officials do not know how many other members of the Class of 2012 have fallen short of meeting the requirements and are thus unable to participate in ceremonies this week. They always offer summer graduation ceremonies, though Goodwin couldn’t say how many diplomas were granted last summer because the district doesn’t aggregate that data.

Students like Shaianne can apply to state education officials for a waiver that would let them participate in their regular graduation ceremony, though without receiving an actual diploma. But the deadline to apply for such a waiver was April 26. Shaianne said it was around May 2 when a school counselor told her she wouldn’t get to walk at graduation.

“They told us and handed us a box of tissues because they knew we were going to cry,” she said. “That kind of ruined Senior Week, and it was the day before prom, too.”

Worse was breaking the news to her mother, she said. The school counselor had Shaianne telephone her mother, she said.

“I couldn’t even speak to her because I was so ashamed,” Shaianne recalled.

Soon after, Shaianne and her mother, Lamusta, went to a school board meeting. Shaianne has attended Cobb schools since kindergarten, and the family has lived in Cobb for nearly 60 years, Lamusta said.

“I didn’t think it was right that these kids don’t get a graduation ceremony,” Lamusta said. “She always struggled with math, but she passed her school classes and got more than enough credits, about three or four more than needed.”

Shaianne now intends to take the math graduation test for a third time in July. The district has scheduled a summer graduation ceremony for 7:30 p.m. July 12 at Osborne High School, and plans to hold another ceremony sometime in August.

“I would have loved to have walked with my class, but I know that wasn’t possible,” Shaianne said.

School Board member Lynnda Eagle, who represents northwest Cobb, said that while she believes strongly in accountability and responsibility, she is glad the summer graduation is an option for students like Shaianne.

“I believe in acknowledging an event as important as high school graduation,” Eagle said. “Not every student progresses at the same rate.”

Beginning with the class of 2015, the state will do away with the graduation tests and instead give more weight to the End-of-Course Tests. Students who entered ninth grade on or after July 1, 2011 will still have to earn required credits, but the End-of-Course Tests will count for 20 percent of their grade.
Comments-icon Post a Comment
May 26, 2012
The state test is not terribly difficult but yet she passed the math class. That says a lot about the education she didnt get.
prof in shock
May 25, 2012
I taught at a local technical college for two years, and I was displeased at the number of students who could not write a complete sentence. Even worse, they would get annoyed when I asked them to do "mundane" things like put a capital letter at the beginning of their sentences or adding punctuation... Passing a graduation test?!
Amen to that
May 25, 2012
My daughter passed the Graduation test on her first try her junior year. She said that it was kind of embarrassingly easy. While I sympathize with this young lady, she needs to realize that graduation is, indeed, a commemorative event that has been EARNED.
My Heart
May 25, 2012
My heart goes out to the parents and students who find themselves unable to participate in the graduation ceremony, but accoding to Cobb Schools, you have no earned it. I support CCCSD 's position because the students begin taking the Graduation tests in the 11th Grade. How many times does one have to be administered an exam to realize you are not ready to graduate? Possibly, students will learn to be present and in class every day and take clases seriously. Students must begin to learn and not just want a grade.
May 25, 2012
graduation test is a joke. If she couldn't pass the test and had the credit to graduate there's a problem with that high school's math teachers. Secondly, she's an idiot.

Common Sense
May 25, 2012
What a liberal "feel bad for me" story when it reeks of "something for nothing mentality." If you don't pass the graduation test for each core subject, you don't pass high school. That is nothing new and there should be no surprises on that one. What the students and parents have grown accustumed to is being passed along without the necessary merit. I am sorry to hear she doesn't get to walk with her peers, but what a strong message of accountability for this young lady that will serve her well into her adult life.
Not All Politics
May 26, 2012
So it's only conservatives who hold people accountable? I am a bleeding-heart liberal who believes you should earn what you get, including grades and high school diplomas.

RIDICULOUS. Stop making everything a political issue.
RE;Common sense
May 26, 2012
Well said. Kids have learned that they can do absolutely nothing and get passed a long..and then they hit high school and expect the same and "surprised" when they don't get the final reward.

Lesson learned (hopefully)
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides