Charges dropped against a student charged with having a knife in his car at Lassiter High
by Leo Hohmann
October 16, 2013 12:17 AM | 8162 views | 6 6 comments | 22 22 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Cody Chitwood
Cody Chitwood
Vic Reynolds
Vic Reynolds
MARIETTA — Lassiter High senior Cody Chitwood’s hobby, fishing, almost got him in trouble, deep trouble, when he forgot some fishing knives in his car and drove to school one day last month.

He stood accused of violating Georgia’s zero-tolerance law for weapons on school campuses and faced two to 10 years in prison and fines of up to $10,000 if convicted.

But he was relieved to hear from his lawyer Tuesday that District Attorney Vic Reynolds has agreed on a deal that will result in the felony charge being dismissed.

Chitwood, 17, will be enrolled in Cobb County’s pretrial diversion program. He may have to do community service and submit to random drug tests, but that beats a ruinous felony conviction that would have haunted him the rest of his life.

He’s also back at school after serving a 10-day suspension.

“It’s good to be back,” he said.

And his plans to enter the Air Force are also back on track.

“My plans are to go in the Air Force, or go to KSU and go through their ROTC program,” he said. “But either way, my long-term goal is to be in the Air Force.”

Reynolds said he and Chitwood’s attorney, Joel Pugh, did not have any difficulty agreeing on a solution.

“His lawyer contacted me end of last week and asked me if I would consider placing him in our pretrial diversion program and if he completes that program, the case against him will be dismissed and expunged from his record. He will have a clean record,” Reynolds said. “I agreed, to make sure he would have nothing on his record where it would affect him in the future. He was concerned about that. I was concerned about that.”

The story, first reported by the Marietta Daily Journal, was picked up by other newspapers, radio and TV stations, including an online article over the weekend by Fox News commentator and former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee.

“My client had no intent to do anything wrong. He’s a good kid. It was simply a mistake,” Pugh said. “He’s an avid fisherman and he forgot he had those knives in the car, and had absolutely no intent to harm anyone or break any school rules whatsoever.”

Pugh said his client has “just been embarrassed by this whole thing. His jail book-in photo has been on the local news, and national news, and he’s a 17-year-old kid.”

Working to rid Georgia of ‘zero tolerance’

Reynolds said he is working with state Sen. Lindsey Tippins (R-west Cobb) and others to change Georgia’s heavy-handed zero-tolerance law.

“In all candor these cases, it’s more of a policy call and the legislators are going to have to look real hard at that law and see if they want it to stay the way it is,” Reynolds said. “But I’m not a real fan of zero-tolerance laws.

“I’ve talked with Sen. Tippins and he’s asked me to help him come up with some language that would put common sense back into the law, and we’re in the process of doing that. We’re just trying to get a little horse sense back in the law.”

Chitwood is not the only local high school senior who has felt the sting of the zero-tolerance weapons law recently.

His arrest occurred about two weeks after that of Andrew Williams, 18, of Acworth. Williams is a senior at Allatoona High School, where he had his vehicle searched for marijuana by an assistant principal, who found no drugs, but did find a pocket knife in the center console. He promptly turned the teen over to campus police, who charged Williams on Sept. 6 with the same felony violation thrown at Chitwood.

Williams’ case has yet to make it to the D.A.’s office ,but now that Chitwood’s case has been placed on a track toward dismissal, it appears unlikely that Williams will be treated more harshly.

“I am going to make a decision very soon on that case,” Reynolds said.

Chitwood has no previous record of arrests or convictions, and his attorney was aggressive in seeking to get the case dismissed.

“Pugh came directly to me and we both agreed that this needs to be resolved quickly so this young man’s future will not be affected,” Reynolds said. “Having to raise two teenagers myself, it concerns me these kids can get jammed up on things because these laws don’t allow for any mitigating circumstances.”

Pugh said he has also been approached by several state legislators hoping to change the law.

“My take on this, to be brutally honest, is that these are well-intentioned laws. I have no doubt this law was passed in reaction to some tragedy that happened somewhere. I just don’t know if it was thoroughly thought out and if anyone realized it would have this type of consequences, because Cody Chitwood is just not the person this was designed to protect us from.

“At the end of the day, I could not be happier at how Vic (Reynolds) treated the case and how the police handled the case.”

From a cop’s perspective

A former cop himself, Reynolds said he knows from experience that most police officers don’t enjoy arresting young people on zero-tolerance infractions.

“What it does is it puts these campus police in a difficult position, and it ends up going up the chain of the system,” he said.

Pugh agrees.

“When you take discretion away from experienced law enforcement officers and judges, that’s something that doesn’t need to happen, ever,” Pugh said. “I’ve known the officer involved in my client’s case for years and know he felt awful about this, but he had absolutely no discretion.”

Besides Tippins in the Senate, Reps. Ed Setzler (R-Acworth) and Rich Golick (R-Smyrna) have also expressed interest in working with Reynolds to, as Setzler said, prevent “the death of common sense” in Georgia’s schools.

Reynolds said he will work with anyone in the General Assembly on this cause. He’s looked at other states’ laws with regard to weapons on school campuses and said Texas may offer some guidance.

“The state of Texas has some statutory language that we think will be a little more appropriate for our state,” he said. “Having been a former police officer myself you don’t check your common sense at the door when you get a badge and a gun; they want to be able to use theirs, but you can’t do it when you have a zero-tolerance law.”

Williams, meanwhile, said he has not been expelled from high school as administrators had previously recommended. He has been assigned to an alternative school and he plans to graduate on time next spring.

“I’m going to get my high school diploma and walk with my class and I should be good, I’m glad, and then I’ll go off and start college,” he said Tuesday.

Williams expressed happiness that Chitwood was being given a way out of the charges and hopes he will be granted the same favor by the D.A.’s office.

“Oh, that’s awesome,” he said.

He plans to apply for enrollment at Georgia Highlands College in Marietta after graduation.

“I’m pretty pumped,” he said.

Comments-icon Post a Comment
October 16, 2013
For the love of God, please get rid of these zero tolerance laws used in our school system. It is horrible that no one gets to explain a situation and be judged on that situation using common sense and reasonable rules. I hate the thought of any kid making a simple mistake and being treated like a felon for it.

How long was the blade of the pocket knife the student had? Isn't it permissible to carry a pocket knife with a blade of 2" or less in a pocket anywhere, even on a government campus?
Just Wait
October 16, 2013
Is is how it is supposed to work. Zero tolerance for the school administration and school system police. No guess work, no gray areas. Prosecutors then have the choice to move forward with the charges or not. They are the ones paid to deal with the gray.
Cobb Taxpayer
October 16, 2013
Solid and resonable resolution !

Now, where are the "thoughtless" legislators who passed this zero common sense law - well intended maybe, but with obvious and foolish natural outcomes - who were these law makers ? They should be retired !
Cobb Citizen
October 16, 2013
I have watched Vic Reynolds make a decision about an investigation, and he considered only "Justice" as his catalyst. We are fortunate to have him as our District Attorney.
obvious elephant
October 16, 2013
Since this child is going to "forget" and leave contraband in his car, he should not be allowed to bring any car to any school campus for the remainder of his tenure in our public schools.

Given our obsession with cars, that would be plenty of punishment and would have the most positive outcome possible for his future if he learns he can, in fact, get by without using a car for ABSOLUETLY EVERYTHING, and that rational sensible successful people can and do get by with leaving their cars parked for days and days on end.

In livable cities, friends have informal competitions for who can go the longest without driving. Imagine that competition in this place... 5 waking hours would win!
cobbbb man
October 16, 2013
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides